Delight Springs

Wednesday, October 18, 2017

Middle Ages

Back from Fall Break. Good times with the family re-united, hiking and biking on the Mountain and in the Domain and in our own backyard.  Now to the not-entirely-dark ages.

[Orig. published March 2017:]

What a summery first day of Spring that was!

Back from the philosophy conference in Birmingham, in Vulcan's shadow, where I was pleased to meet John Kaag and thank him for his American Philosophy: A Love Story. He's a peripatetic too, noting that "walking gives one many things," especially time and attention. “Looking back," he writes, "I had the realization that at one point in the not-so-distant past, philosophy wasn’t the sort of thing that was discussed only at formal conferences and in arcane journals. It was exchanged over dinner, between families. It was the stuff of everyday life." And, “The love of wisdom was not bound in academic journals that no one read; it rather permeated all aspects of human existence.”

And most pointedly: "The point of American philosophy isn't to be 'right'... is not to have a specific rock-solid point, but rather to outline a problem, explore its context, get a sense of the whole experiential situation..." Always good to remember, at a conference. SAAP conferees tend to remember it better than some others.

Then, I contributed my small bit to the William James Society's panel discussion of immortality "re-envisioned"and "Existential Pluralism" and reaffirmed our continuing commitment as public philosophers to the ongoing project of constructively melding and applying American philosophy's traditional elements - pragmatism, pluralism, radical empiricism, and especially meliorism. Some of my friends find it very difficult to do that, on paper. In practice, and in the spirit of James, I don't see how we can possibly fail to try.

I'm with him: "I am willing that every leaf that ever grew in this world's forests and rustled in the breeze should become immortal. It is purely a question: are the leaves so, or not?" Only time and experience will finally tell. In the meantime, we must remember: "The inner significance of other lives exceeds all our powers of sympathy and insight. If we feel a significance in our own life which would lead us spontaneously to claim its perpetuity, let us be at least tolerant of like claims made by other lives."  Let us not let "blindness lay down the law to sight." And let us not stamp out possibilities, prematurely. [My wife reminded me of that, out on the patio at Bar Louie in downtown Nashville yesterday, as I gazed longingly at the upscale high-rise condos and wished for the possibility of reincarnation, to see what it would be like to live up there.]

The most compelling and most vulnerable possibility these days, surely, is the very continuation of lives worth living. The really vital question persists: what is life going to make of itself, on this earth of things? That's the existential question. As Billy Collins says in today's poem ("The Order of the Day"), you never really know.

In late antiquity and the middle ages the big questions tended to be more about life's rumored sequel and how to achieve it. Augustine first thought you had to make alliance with the forces of good, in their death struggle with the forces of darkness. He was on the right track, I tend to think, before his big conversion. He was right to suppose that our side needs all good hands on deck, to resist and overcome evil. He put that conversion off as long as he could, praying for purity but only in due course. For the record, though: I don't think he was right to think of our carnal condition as an entombment. Incorporeal souls sow no wild oats, ascetics enjoy few existential delights.

So, buoyed by Platonism, he "put all forms of materialism firmly behind him" and "turned back the clock of intellectual history." The old Greek commitment to reason was not finally comforting enough to him. "He returned to a version of the comforting supernatural stories which most of the first philosophers sought to dispense with, or at least to rationalize."

Boethius's Consolation of Philosophy dialogue found its own form of comfort, not in Augustine's Christianity but in Lady Philosophy's timeless stoicism. God (or Good?) sees all in a single atemporal sweep, "at a go," and thus somehow leaves the hapless victim of tortured persecution and execution as free as it found him. He can still choose to be "philosophical" about every misfortune, even to his dying breath on the rack. His freedom's a lot like Kris Kristofferson's and Janis Joplin's, "just another word for nothing left to lose."

Anselm's God, "than which nothing greater can be conceived," and his famous "proof" thereof, is another of those notorious sleights of hand made to do heavy philosophical lifting with nothing more muscular than verbiage. It's still shocking to me, how many bright people (including young Russell, briefly) it's seduced. 

Speaking of great misfortune, poor Abelard's is painful to ponder. Gottlieb blames "his scholarly prowess and his passionate involvement with logic" for emboldening him to undertake his own fateful seduction. How ironic, that he would go on to make his mark as "the first serious moral philosopher of medieval times" and "to apply rational analysis to the nature of moral goodness." Too little, too late.

Moses Maimonides did not address Abelard's peculiar form of perplexity but did try to bring philosophy, science, and religion together. “Truth does not become more true by virtue of the fact that the entire world agrees with it, nor less so even if the whole world disagrees with it.” But try telling that to the world. He was right, though. “You must accept the truth from whatever source it comes.” But, “Do not consider it proof just because it is written in books, for a liar who will deceive with his tongue will not hesitate to do the same with his pen.”

He was onto confirmation bias early. “We naturally like what we have been accustomed to, and are attracted towards it. [...] The same is the case with those opinions of man to which he has been accustomed from his youth; he likes them, defends them, and shuns the opposite views.”

Was he really the first to say this?: “Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day; teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime.” Did he anticipate James's Will to Believe notion that "our errors are not such awfully solemn things"? “The risk of a wrong decision is preferable to the terror of indecision.”

He was sort of a bioethicist before his time: “The physician should not treat the disease but the patient who is suffering from it.” And, “No disease that can be treated by diet should be treated with any other means.” Actually that might have helped Abelard, with a little timely saltpeter in his diet.

William of Ockham's famous "razor" said we should keep our theories simple, our ontology thin. "It is pointless to do with more what can be done with less." Remember Goober's beard?

Remember Buridan's Ass? Apparently "no such animal appears in his writings." Too bad, he's been such a workhorse for logicians.

Giordano Bruno was a mystic friar, but he also had a vivd scifi imagination. He said there must be other worlds and "countless suns" out there in the Void, "innumerable globes like this on which we live and grow." We've only confirmed that in the past twenty years or so. It (and other heresies) got him torched in 1600. Carl Sagan and Neil Tyson tell his story.

Finally today, Aquinas. His First Cause Argument, echoing Aristotle, said a never-ending series of causes and effects would lead to an unacceptable regress. The first term in any explanatory sequence, he thought, has to be self-evident. But is that itself self-evident? Russell says, of "the supposed impossibility of a series having no first term: Every mathematician knows that there is no such impossibility; the series of negative integers ending with minus one is an instance to the contrary. But here again no Catholic is likely to abandon belief in God even if he becomes convinced that Saint Thomas's arguments are bad; he will invent other arguments, or take refuge in revelation." It's not just Catholics. Remember confirmation bias?

More questions: Can the definition of a word prove anything about the world? Is theoretical simplicity always better, even if the universe is complex? Does the possibility of other worlds somehow diminish humanity? Which is more plausible, that God exists but is not more powerful than Satan, or that neither God nor Satan exists? Why? Are supernatural stories of faith, redemption, and salvation comforting to you than the power of reason and evidence? And what do you say to Carl Sagan?:
“The world is so exquisite with so much love and moral depth, that there is no reason to deceive ourselves with pretty stories for which there's little good evidence. Far better it seems to me, in our vulnerability, is to look death in the eye and to be grateful every day for the brief but magnificent opportunity that life provides.”
“Science is not only compatible with spirituality; it is a profound source of spirituality. When we recognize our place in an immensity of light‐years and in the passage of ages, when we grasp the intricacy, beauty, and subtlety of life, then that soaring feeling, that sense of elation and humility combined, is surely spiritual. So are our emotions in the presence of great art or music or literature, or acts of exemplary selfless courage such as those of Mohandas Gandhi or Martin Luther King, Jr. The notion that science and spirituality are somehow mutually exclusive does a disservice to both.” 
[More good questions here... ]
==
It was on this day in 1954 that the first transistor radio appeared on the market.

Transistors were a big breakthrough in electronics — a new way to amplify signals. They replaced vacuum tubes, which were fragile, slow to warm up, and unreliable... With transistor radios, teenagers were able to listen to music out of their parents' earshot. This made possible the explosion of a new genre of American music: rock and roll. WA

On this day in 1867 US takes formal possession of Alaska from Russia having paid $7.2 million... 1922 British Broadcasting Company (BBC) founded, later called British Broadcasting Corporation... 1962 James Watson (US), Francis Crick (UK) and Maurice Wilkins (UK) win the Nobel Prize for Medicine for their work in determining the structure of DNA
==
3.14.17. Happy birthday J.S. Bach, who said “I play the notes as they are written, but it is God who makes the music.” That's not what Dan Dennett says in From Bacteria to Bach and Back. “You shouldn’t trust your intuitions. Conceivability or inconceivability is a life’s work—it’s not something where you just screw up your head for a second!”

The Alabama Freedom March began on this date in 1965. The Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King and 3,200 demonstrators set off on a 54-mile march from Selma to Montgomery, Alabama, to protest the disenfranchisement of black voters... WA
5:30/6:50, 59/73/46, 6:57 

Thursday, October 12, 2017

Spinoza's joy

Today in Happiness we finish Frederic Lenoir's Happiness: A Philosopher's Guide. It's an answer to the SoL's charge that western academic philosophy no longer offers the kind of therapeutic balm and succor, the therapy, that inspired the Hellenistic Age. We have resources too, if you're willing to cherry-pick your western medicine: a little Stoicism here, a little Epicureanism there, a little Spinoza, a little Plato (not Prozac)...

But first, a word of appreciation for our reporters last time. That mindful moment out on the Peck Hall stoa, framed by a gentle rain, was calming. We should do that again.

Spinoza was mindful in his way. His possessions were few: books, desk, optical workshop, the four-poster bed of both his conception and his demise. Do people who retain tangible continuity with the familiar furniture of their lives, over a lifetime, find peace of mind easier to have and hold?
He wanted to free us from the "cruel illusion" of free will, in deference to the "spinozism of freedom" (as my old teacher called it) that he found in surrender to causal necessity. To be free, in these terms, is to shelve the will and find liberation in rational understanding. It's to transcend the narrow and selfish ego, to discard the sense of personal marginality and alienation, to embrace the widest possible identity in the whole.

Does that identity squeeze out particularity and individualism? Not in Lenoir's interpretation. "We must all learn to know ourselves in order to discover what makes us happy or unhappy..." 

Well, good. Great. But what if we discover that what makes us happy is the sense of ourselves as causal agents whose wills do sometimes find expression in purposive activity that makes a difference, that alters events and creates alternative futures? What if we desire that identity? Is it a bad desire?

"The role of reason then consists not in judging and reprimanding a bad desire (as morality does), but in arousing new desires, more securely established, that will bring us greater joy." Lenoir offers the example of his niece, whom he says reason instructed to desire a more serious approach to school. Reason, not will, "enabled her to do all that was necessary..." (165) Are we sure about that? I'm not.

To be happy we must "focus on energizing the forces of life: to nourish joy, love, compassion, kindness, tolerance, benevolent thoughts, self-esteem..." Sounds like a big job for reason alone.

Is "joy" a passing emotion or a "permanent feeling"? It can be both, surely. But our "essential truth" is that "joy of living" that engenders gratitude, harmony, peace, and freedom. Spinoza's way is one path, but it's not the only one. Lenoir's last words echo some of what we heard on Tuesday about finding happiness within ourselves, urging indispensable "inner labor". Agreed, but again with the proviso that inner work must eventually connect with outer exertion, must translate into engagement and not, finally, detachment.

Some questions: Can we freely choose to renounce free will? Or freely choose to affirm it? Or seek new desires? (Remember Schopenhauer's "We can do what we want, but not want what we want.") Why shouldn't we expect a pantheistic universe to yield universal rules of behavior? Can a rationalist- pantheist endorse delusional sources of happiness? 178 Was Einstein being disingenous when he affirmed "Spinoza's God"? If  "there isn't an inch of earth where God is not," does God not have a lot to answer for?
==
It was on this day in 1892 that the Pledge of Allegiance was recited en masse for the first time, by more than 2 million students. It had been written just a month earlier by a Baptist minister named Francis Bellamy, who published it in Youth's Companion and distributed it across the country. It was recited on this day to celebrate the 400th anniversary of Columbus's arrival in the Americas... It's the birthday of author and psychologist Robert Coles (books by this author), born in Boston, Massachusetts (1929). He's the author of more than 60 books. Coles was in the South at the dawn of the civil rights movement, planning to lead a low-key life as a child psychologist. But one day, during a visit to New Orleans in 1960, he saw a white mob surrounding a six-year-old black girl named Ruby Bridges, who was kneeling in her starched white dress in the middle of it all to pray for the mob that was attacking her. Coles decided to begin what would become his work for the next few decades, an effort to understand how children and their parents come to terms with radical change. He conducted hundreds of interviews on the effects of school desegregation, and he shaped them into the first volume of Children of Crisis (1967), a series of books for which he won the Pulitzer Prize in 1973... He said, "We should look inward and think about the meaning of our life and its purposes, lest we do it in 20 or 30 years and it's too late." WA

Tuesday, October 10, 2017

Stoics, Skeptics, & Taoists

We're looking for points of contact between eastern and western notions of happiness today in Happiness. Epictetus the Stoic said its our judgments about things (including people) that disturb us, not things (or people). Shantideva the Buddhist sage said it's better to "kill the spirit of hatred" rather than go after the haters one by one. The spirit, like the judgment, resides within oneself.

That may be strategically sound, but those who've actually witnessed White Supremacist rallies (for instance) testify that the spirit was all too manifest and out in the open. My judgment about such people is about such people, not just about itself. Is the best way to combat them really through an inward turn? Maybe, if the inner transformation then radiates in the form of action towards social justice. Detach from hatred, then attach to reform. Repeat as needed.

Does it help to replace anthropomorphic gods with a pantheistic sense of divine unity? You'd have to accept the bundle, wouldn't you, bad apples and all? The world is one but it's also many, including many joys and sorrows. I can affirm the former without reservation, but less of the latter would have to be better.

Epictetus's dogcart analogy suggests "we need to unite our wills with the necessity of destiny." Are we the dog? Or the cart-driver? I'll accept the journey and even enjoy it if I know my intended destination.

If we cannot ever "bend the world to our desires" we may as well stop seeking satisfaction. What if we can occasionally bend it a bit, though? That might be enough reward for our effort to elicit more, for many.

Samsara, the cycle of birth, suffering, death, and rebirth that Buddhists say sustains our "erroneous perception of reality," is (they say) rooted in desire. But the desire to ameliorate suffering does not distort reality, it improves it. The problem isn't desire per se, it's too many of the wrong desires and not enough of the good ones. No?
Cosmopolitanism, for my money, is the Stoics' greatest invention. We're all citizens of the world, indeed the cosmos, and can be trained to desire the good of all sentient beings. Narcissistic individualism is just a stage, if we're smart enough to enter training.

Chuang Tzu and Montaigne both liked to laugh. "These two skeptics mock the dogmatic, enjoy relating irreverent anecdotes, deride the complacent and are able to laugh at themselves..." Que scay-je? What, me worry? But don't get carried away, skeptic, "seek a balance between dogmatism and skepticism... 'reach an opinion and [don't] hesitate to proffer it'..." Montaigne's wisdom, says Lenoir, "comes down to a sort of great, sacred 'yes' to life." His yes seems more genuinely affirming than Nietzsche's, seems to me. We'll talk about that later.

Taoist paradoxes can be frustratingly cryptic: forget yourself to find yourself, try not to try etc. Apparently that frustration is supposed to be instigating and revealing, not just annoying. 

But I am a bit annoyed by the suggestion that we should be "content with the radiance [of the sun] without trying to scrutinize its source." We need to understand the source, and thereby intensify our contentment and magnify our competence to replicate the radiance. You don't have to be a Platonist about suns and Forms of the Good to think so.

Some questions: Do you agree that things are inherently neutral, with respect to their bearing on your happiness, and that it's only your opinion of them that matters? In general, what's your attitude towards desire and attachment? Are they obstacles to happiness or prerequisites for it?
How important are "willpower" and self-control to your happiness? What can you do to strengthen them? What does "Living the present" mean to you? Is there a problem with it, as either a goal or a possible attainment? Does anticipating bad possibilities (as Cicero did with his daily praemeditatio) make you happier in the long run, or less so? What did John Lennon mean by "instant karma"? (It was his birthday yesterday, he'd have been 77. Hard to imagine.)
==
It's playwright Harold Pinter's birthday. He said: "How can you write a happy play? Drama is about conflict and general degrees of perturbation, disarray. I've never been able to write a happy play, but I've been able to enjoy a happy life." WA... and on this day in 1899, "African-American inventor Issac R. Johnson patents the bicycle frame"...


Thursday, October 5, 2017

Individual & collective happiness etc.

What fun in Happiness last time, listening to Kyle's Happy Playlist and pondering our own. How sobering, though, to see Robin Williams cavorting on the Bobby McFerrin's "Don't worry, be happy" video in full knowledge of his tragic self-negating destiny. But perhaps it's not accurate to say he took his own life, rather that life's vicissitudes and invasive mental disease took it from him. Before then he made a lot of people happy and dispatched a lot of gratuitous worry. So sad he couldn't do the same, ultimately, for himself. But mental illness is like a hurricane, there's only so much you can do to prepare for it. Luck is also required.

What would we add to the list? Mine had to include The Beatles' In My Life, leading to Hey Jude, to When I'm 64... And thinking of Tom Petty, a Resilience soundtrack would be a great sequel. That's the quality of character these times seem most to require and will most reward. 

Today in Happiness we begin with a surprising statement from Spinoza: "When each man most seeks his own advantage for himself, then men are most useful to one another." That's discordant with the notes we sounded last time against "visceral egoists" and for altruists. But pantheists don't really believe in individuals and their egos, certainly not in an Ayn Randian sense. He did believe that happiness comes from identification with the most inclusive whole we can conceive. So, I wonder what Lenoir intends with that decontextualized epigraph.

Would we rather be happy than "sublime or saved"? Not sure we have to face that choice. "Earthly happiness" checks both of those boxes, for me (and Voltaire). Note to class: register for PHIL 3310, "Atheism & Philosophy" next semester if you want to pursue that question. It's distinctly related to the modern bifurcation Lenoir deplores, the separation of individual well-being from the common good.

Michel Houellebecq writes all about "narcissistic individualism: his characters are apathetic, egoistic, frustrated, cynical...joyless hedonis[ts]" who wouldn't know the meaning of individual good if it bit them. He seems to think they are us.

But who are we really? Lenoir's friend Bruckner thinks "we are probably the first societies in history to make people unhappy about not being happy... the obsession with happiness often thwarts happiness." How depressing. Irony is supposed to make you smile, at least, isn't it?

And oh by the way, depression is a symptom of our unhappy obsession and a reflection of our question for self-realization without adequate social support. Making matters worse, nature has wired us to look for trouble. "We become more aware of negative events... dissatisfaction makes us strive constantly for more and better things." Can we learn to take satisfaction in our very dissatisfaction, to see it as emblematic (again) of our capacity for resilience? Don't back down, get back up, be happy. Is that a formula we can work with?

Another question today points back to J.S. Mill's "durable joy" and delight in feeling, after much too much thinking. "Would you become blase, were all your desires satisfied?" Mill perplexed himself with the realization that fulfilling all his intellectual and social/political goals would leave him no happier than before. Then he broadened his portfolio of desires to include Wordsworth. We can learn from that too, not necessarily from Wordsworth (though also not necessarily not). Our poetry may be music, and "the music can commence again..." Silly music (and poetry) is sometimes the best balm. Take it away Eric...

Squeeze this one into the Happy/Resilient playlist too. "It's alright," as Tom sings, "I'm just glad to be here, happy to be alive... at the end of the line."
==
It’s the birthday of American astrophysicist and author Neil deGrasse Tyson (1958) (books by this author), who once said, “The universe is under no obligation to make sense to you.” Tyson is the host of the popular shows Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey and Star Talk. He grew up in the Bronx and remembers visiting the Hayden Planetarium’s Sky Theatre on a school field trip, which inspired his interest in astronomy and science. He said, “So strong was that imprint [of the night sky] that I’m certain that I had no choice in the matter, that in fact, the universe called me.” He’s now the director of the Planetarium. Tyson’s television shows, podcasts, and books have inspired millions of people to see the universe with new eyes.
He’s so popular that he has appeared as himself in television shows and movies like The Big Bang Theory, The Simpsons, and Zoolander 2. He’s also been featured as himself in comic books like Action Comics #14, in which he discusses Superman’s home planet of Krypton.
On the importance of explaining complex science to the layman, Tyson once said: “Humans want to think that they’re the center of the world. Children think this way. Then you come into adulthood and it’s a little disappointing to learn that’s not the case. We still think of events happening locally, in our lifetimes, as significant in a way that is out of proportion with reality. This can be depressing to some people, if you come into it with a high ego. If you go into it with no ego at all, you realize that you can be special not for being different, but for being a participant in life on Earth. That participation, if you’re open to it, can be quite illuminating, even sort of spiritually uplifting. You’re a part of all of life on Earth. Earth is part of all the planets that exist in the galaxy. The galaxy is part of an entire system of the universe.”
Tyson’s books include Death by Black Hole (2007) and Astrophysics for People in a Hurry (2017).

It’s the birthday of scientist Robert Hutchings Goddard, born in Worcester, Massachusetts (1882), who is known as the “Father of the Space Age.” From childhood, Goddard had been fascinated by space travel, finding inspiration in part from H.G. Wells’s War of the Worlds. He began studying physics at Worcester Polytechnic Institute and as a student he decided that the most effective propellant would be a combination of liquid hydrogen and liquid oxygen. In 1926, he discovered an even more effective liquid fuel combination: gasoline and liquid oxygen. He launched the world’s first liquid-propelled rocket, a small device that went up 41 feet and landed 184 feet away. In 1930, Goddard moved his operations to Roswell, New Mexico, establishing the world’s first professional rocket proving ground. WA
Now to Happiness: A History... 

Tuesday, October 3, 2017

Contagious happiness

"Are you happy?" is too unequivocal, too binary a question for Frederic Lenoir. Our happiness is a sliding continuum, "and our impression of happiness fluctuates with time."  A lot of us slide back, in the wake of an atrocity like Las Vegas. Most of us will slide forward again, eventually (and the meliorists among us, like Nick Kristof, will immediately look beyond the prayers and the mourning and the attributions of "pure evil" to what we can do (like stand up to the NRA, Rosanne?)... and of course, the BSers will exploit the situation with their insidious fakery.

Tom Petty has died. In 2006 he told Terry Gross about the elation he felt after losing his home and everything in it (except his family) to an arsonist and would-be murderer. He learned the lesson we all have to keep learning again and again: just being alive can be enough.. until it isn't. He wrote "I Won't Back Down" as a celebratory anthem of resolute happiness and endurance, inspired a lot of people to buck up and carry on, suffered a serious depression years later. And again, he got better. Not backing down, for most of us, is more about getting back up. Resilience.

Insights like J.S. Mill's, on the durable sources of joy amidst life's travails, grease the skids that get us back on our happy tracks. He was raised by his overbearing Pop to think, but (with an assist from the poet Wordsworth) taught himself to find joy in feeling.
What made Wordsworth’s poems a medicine for my state of mind, was that they expressed, not mere outward beauty, but states of feeling, and of thought coloured by feeling, under the excitement of beauty. They seemed to be the very culture of the feelings, which I was in quest of. In them I seemed to draw from a source of inward joy, of sympathetic and imaginative pleasure, which could be shared in by all human beings; which had no connexion with struggle or imperfection, but would be made richer by every improvement in the physical or social condition of mankind. From them I seemed to learn what would be the perennial sources of happiness, when all the greater evils of life shall have been removed… I needed to be made to feel that there was real, permanent happiness in tranquil contemplation. Wordsworth taught me this…
Adam Etinson concludes, in The Stone, that "we all have the ability to find some durable joy in quietude, normalcy and contemplation... [to] escape Schopenhauer’s pendulum: to simply enjoy where we are, at times; to find some peace in the cessation of motion."

It's become a commonplace to say that most people revert, after confronting serious illness, career disappointment, traumatic violence, or (alternately) a positive event, to their happiness "fixed point." We may not want to hear that, but in times like these it's probably good news. Lenoir says he's found it possible to "break through to new levels," and the bare possibility may be enough to keep most of us in active pursuit. Even if we generally revert to form, it's nice to ponder the perpetual possibility of a breakthrough.

The "age effect" will dispirit most students, if they think they have to wait for their sixth decade to begin experiencing a "notable rise"... followed by a new phase of decline after seventy. Guess I should be having the time of my life right now, in the "mellowness of maturity." I'd like to counter that you're only as old as you feel, but from an aches-and-pains perspective that's not always so reassuring. I prefer to collect inspiring examples of octogenerians, nonagenerians, and centenarians who've flourished in the autumn and early winter of life, people like Stewart Udall, Will Durant, Jimmy Carter... but not Hef.

Friendship (philia), Aristotle was surely right to say, is for most a crucial condition of happiness. "Visceral egoists" are not great friends, if you need a reason to reject that attitude. Altruists, on the other hand, are terrific. Not sure I agree with Lenoir and Ricard that "human nature is fundamentally good," but I've known many natures who were. Unfortunately, the human nature scale is also a continuum that runs the gamut and includes the likes of the Las Vegas shooter.

"Every happy friend increases our probability of being happy by 9 percent" but misery also loves company. I still wonder about the impact of happy pessimists, if we've agreed that there are such critters. 

The "shared rapture" of rooting for a winning team can indeed be upliftng, but unlike the biblical rapture it doesn't last. Wait 'til next year. Next week. Tomorrow.

Are we really "almost all 'more or less happy'" most of the time? We're up and down the scale, for sure, and that would seem to mitigate the suggestion that we might realistically aim to be"happy every moment" - unless we've followed Aristotle's program and decoupled eudaimonia from every moment. The visceral egoists deserve to fail every program, if life were fair.

Finally: if shaudenfreude can be explained in evolutionary terms, cooperation and mutual support can too. We can learn to take pleasure in others' happiness. Nurture, as we were saying yesterday, can improve our nature.

And as William James said, even after a desolating event "the music can commence again and again..." That's your cue, Kyle. I hope your happiness soundtrack will cheer us all up. Does it include any Tom Petty (R.I.P.)? Traveling Wilburys, maybe? Don't back down, be happy.
==
Today is the birthday of Harvey Kurtzman (1924) (books by this author), cartoonist and creator of MAD Magazine... Critics see the magazine as a forerunner for much of American satire that came after it, including The Simpsons, The Daily Show, and The Colbert Report. Art Spiegelman, the writer of the graphic novel Maus, said, “The message MAD had in general is, ‘The media is lying to you, and we are part of the media.’ It was basically … ‘Think for yourselves, kids.’” WA

Thursday, September 28, 2017

Brains, Proust, & Woody

Today in Happiness we look at the brain and its molecules of emotion, and at attention and dreaming. (Lenoir 10-12)

The brain regarding itself is an uncanny experience, isn't it? Persons aren't just brains, of course, but the seat of conscious thought seems like a good place to search for leverage when addressing the happiness of a whole person. That's a bootstrap operation if ever there was one. Pull yourself up by your neurotransmitters, one might implore. But we mustn't forget, "neurotransmitters are hampered by an unbalanced diet, emotional upset and a lack of sleep." Brains don't exist in a vacuum.

 Dopamine, oxytocin, and serotonin have much to do with happiness, as indicated by brain imaging research. They impact our appetite for life, motivation, decision-making, intro/extroversion, impulsiveness, violence, trust, empathy, generosity, creativity, intuition, sociability, adventurousness, memory, capacity for enjoyment, optimism, contentment, serenity, sleep... Is there anything they don't have to do with? Do they explain too much, leaving too little to what we like to think of as our spontaneous characters and personalities? Do those explain anything at all, after all? Should we feel threatened by all this talk of chemically-induced happiness or misery? Should we feel diminished, or empowered?

"Our happiness is nourished by the quality of attention we bring to bear on what we are doing," said the old Stoics and Epicureans.

"My experience is what I agree to attend to, said William James, and "Attention … is the taking possession by the mind, in clear and vivid form, of one out of what seem several simultaneously possible objects or trains of thought, localization, concentration, of consciousness are of its essence. It implies withdrawal from some things in order to deal effectively with others..." When we fail to deploy attention selectively and with intention, our world becomes a "gray chaotic indiscriminateness." Brainpickings

When we do attend to our experience with selective intelligence, we open ourselves to the delighted "dilution" of awareness known as reverie. That's why Montaigne rode his horse, and got back in the saddle after a near-fatal dismount. It's why I walk the dogs, or why the dogs and I walk each other: I defy anyone to interpret my dachsund/beagle's evidently-delighted expression, when in full exuberant stride, as anything short of reverie. I try to learn from him, daily, how to live in the present.

We've noted, recall, that there's a problem about that, and an Aristotelian solution.
These days, many of us would rather not be living in the present, a time of persistent crisis, political uncertainty and fear. Not that the future looks better, shadowed by technological advances that threaten widespread unemployment and by the perils of catastrophic climate change. No wonder some are tempted by the comforts of a nostalgically imagined past.
Inspiring as it seems on first inspection, the self-help slogan “live in the present” slips rapidly out of focus. What would living in the present mean? To live each day as if it were your last, without a thought for the future, is simply bad advice, a recipe for recklessness. The idea that one can make oneself invulnerable to what happens by detaching from everything but the present is an irresponsible delusion.
Despite this, there is an interpretation of living in the present, inspired by Aristotle, that can help us to confront the present crisis and the perpetual crises of struggle and failure in life. There is an insight in the self-help slogan that philosophy can redeem... (continues)
The present moment, specious though it is, lends itself to attention and reverie for those who learn to notice and form appropriately attentive habits. See Duhigg, The Power of Habit (“This is the real power of habit: the insight that your habits are what you choose them to be”) and Gallagher, Rapt: Attention and the Focused Life (“Einstein didn't invent the theory of relativity while he was multitasking at the Swiss patent office.")

But presence passes, and so our happiness also depends crucially on memory and the ability to "dig up happy times." That's what the author of À la recherche du temps perdu was about, with his cookies etc. (And there's my entry in the "All England Summarize Proust" competition.)

Lenoir recuses Schopenhauer from membership in the Woody Allen school of pessimism ("life is 'a grim, painful, nightmarish experience ... the only way that you an be happy is if you tell yourself some lies and deceive yourself") and actually implies that he might better belong with Martin Seligman and the Positive Psychologists who "insist on the need to develop our positive thoughts while eliminating our old negative beliefs," if we want authentic happiness... but also say we should "avoid having too many hopes and fears." Sounds a lot like Stoicism.

Lenoir doesn't quote Woody's paradoxical caveat: life is painful, nightmarish, etc. etc., and "it's all over much too soon." Go figure.
==
The Playboy Philosopher has died. 
...In “The Playboy Philosophy,” a mix of libertarian and libertine arguments that Mr. Hefner wrote in 25 installments starting in 1962, his message was simple: Society was to blame. His causes — abortion rights, decriminalization of marijuana and, most important, the repeal of 19th-century sex laws — were daring at the time. Ten years later, they would be unexceptional... “Hefner won,” Todd Gitlin said in a 2015 interview. “The prevailing values in the country now, for all the conservative backlash, are essentially libertarian, and that basically was what the Playboy Philosophy was. It’s laissez-faire. It’s anti-censorship. It’s consumerist: Let the buyer rule. It’s hedonistic. In the longer run, Hugh Hefner’s significance is as a salesman of the libertarian ideal.”
The Playboy Philosophy advocated freedom of speech in all its aspects, for which Mr. Hefner won civil liberties awards. He supported progressive social causes and lost some sponsors by inviting black guests to his televised parties at a time when much of the nation still had Jim Crow laws... Mr. Hefner said later that he was perplexed by feminists’ apparent rejection of the message he had set forth in the Playboy Philosophy. “We are in the process of acquiring a new moral maturity and honesty,” he wrote in one installment, “in which man’s body, mind and soul are in harmony rather than in conflict.” Of Americans’ fright of anything “unsuitable for children,” he said, “Instead of raising children in an adult world, with adult tastes, interests and opinions prevailing, we prefer to live much of our lives in a make-believe children’s world...” nyt
...Women in the magazine were intended more as the girl next door than as sex objects. Still, the fact that they were often topless (full nudity didn’t appear until 1972) brought criticism that Mr. Hefner objectified women and promoted an unrealistic standard of female beauty, that women should be subservient playmates for the modern man. To Mr. Hefner, women were simply a part of the interests of most heterosexual men. The magazine featured discussions of equal rights, contraception and reproductive choice for women. Mr. Hefner never saw that as a contradiction... ("How Hefner Invented the Modern Man")
==
Today we celebrate the birthday of the teacher, philosopher, and political theorist popularly known as Confucius, born near what is now Qufu, in Shandong Province, China, in 551 BCE... His birthday is an official holiday in Taiwan, where it is celebrated as Teachers’ Day. His writings were first translated into English by James Legge in 1867, and a more readable translation was published by Oxford University in 1907.

Confucius wrote: “There are three things which the wise man holds in reverence: the Will of Heaven, those in authority, and the words of the sages. The fool knows not the Will of Heaven and holds it not in reverence: he is disrespectful to those in authority; he ridicules the words of the sages.”

And: “He who does not understand the Will of God can never be a man of the higher type. He who does not understand the inner law of self-control can never stand firm. He who does not understand the force of words can never know his fellow-men.” WA

Tuesday, September 26, 2017

Schopenhauer happy?

Today in Happiness we tackle Schopenhauer, who always seems to hover around our discussions. We kicked off the semester with his potentially disillusioning (but also potentially liberating?) disavowal of the whole subject.

“What disturbs and depresses young people is the hunt for happiness on the firm assumption that it must be met with in life. From this arises constantly deluded hope and so also dissatisfaction. Deceptive images of a vague happiness hover before us in our dreams, and we search in vain for their original. Much would have been gained if, through timely advice and instruction, young people could have had eradicated from their minds the erroneous notion that the world has a great deal to offer them.”

And yet, we noted him last time explicitly identifying health as a condition of happiness. So, he throws not a total disavowal but at least a big dash of cold water into every smiling face.

Likewise, his statement that "man can do what he wills but he cannot will what he wills.” The intended implication may be that health and happiness alike are a matter of luck, not design. The inevitable rejoinder, from happy people everywhere, must be Branch Rickey's: sometimes, at least, luck is the residue of design. Get happy.

 Carl Jung's "process of individuation," I'll bet, hits philosophers and philosophy majors earlier than most and before forty, for sure. Isn't that why we take courses like this, to get to the bottom of our "true individuality" and "pay more attention to our own sensibility"-even if only to challenge and replace it with a corrected view?

Goethe suggested that sensibility, character, and taste are less affected by externals than by the sheer spontaneous surge of "personal being" that defines "a child of Earth's chief happiness," but that's not Schopenhauer's (or the Buddha's) view. Or is it?

Frederic Lenoir says Schopenhauer "took up Goethe's idea and went even further... our nature predisposes us to be happy or unhappy." But Will is not personal for him. How we respond to the hypothesis of implacable impersonal Will might be. 

Plato long ago distinguished grouches (duskolos) from more cheerful types (eukolos). But as some self-avowed grouches insist, whether the glass is happily half-full depends on what's in it.

Schopenhauer's "curious contradiction" suggests we can be determinists and at the same time be happier, mostly by acknowledging Will and then not choosing not to feed it. Lenoir says that's not what he means by changing our inner lives. "We can be happier... by modifying our view of things, our thoughts and beliefs." We can "will what we will," then? But can we confirm that we can? Is it better if we can't?

Sonja Lyubomirsky says 40% of happiness "stems from personal efforts," a vague-enough statement to entertain if not entirely to understand. I'm hoping that won't be conclusively disconfirmed, 40% sounds good even if it implies a slight tilt to genetic predisposition that we probably shouldn't call determinism and certainly shouldn't call fatalism.

"No one will be happy if tormented by the thought of someone else who is happier," said Seneca before surrendering his own happy pursuit to the madness of the tormentor Nero.

Flaubert said "everyone takes his enjoyment in his own way and for himself alone." Some do, but there are altruists among us who aren't in it for themselves alone. The egocentric view may reassure hyper-egoists, but I hope the rest of us find it beside the point. 

Do we all have a peculiarly personal "deeper nature"? If you find the "atmosphere that suits" you best, have you found something deep? Must atmospheres be deep, to conduce to happiness? Or just, as the pluralists say, wide enough, at least, to accommodate the varieties of happy experience?
==
"Today is the birthday of American composer and musician George Gershwin (1898), whose lyrical and jazzy pieces, like Rhapsody in Blue, “Summertime,” “I Got Rhythm,” and “Embraceable You,” have become part of the American Songbook and influenced musicians like Charlie Parker and Janis Joplin... he composed “Rhapsody in Blue” '1924), what many consider his masterpiece, in a manic frenzy. He’d been having dinner with his brother when they read a newspaper article saying Gershwin would be performing a new piece in public in two weeks, which he didn’t know about. He’d been inspired to write the piece on a train ride... "I heard it as a sort of musical kaleidoscope of America, of our vast melting pot, of our unduplicated national pep, of our metropolitan madness. By the time I reached Boston I had a definite plot of the piece, as distinguished from its actual substance.'

When he performed the piece in public for the first time, Gershwin improvised some of what he was playing, and he didn’t write out the piano part until after the performance, so it’s unknown exactly how the original Rhapsody sounded, but it changed popular music forever. The soundtrack to the Woody Allen movie, Manhattan (1979) is composed entirely of Gershwin’s compositions, including Rhapsody in Blue...he died at the age of 38. He’d been behaving oddly for weeks and his doctors said he’d been suffering from a fast-growing, malignant brain tumor. Now, doctors say his erratic behavior and years-long battle with depression might have been the brain tumor all along and that Gershwin was likely misdiagnosed..." WA

Thursday, September 21, 2017

Voltaire, Socrates, Jesus, Kant

Interesting quartet, in Happiness today.

Voltaire's response to my question the other day, as to whether any of us ever regret the examined life and would occasionally prefer to swap places with Forrest Gump or Winnie the Pooh, is as acerbic as you'd expect. "I should be happy if I were as brainless as my neighbor, and yet I do not desire such happiness." Maybe he'd have been happy to live in a better neighborhood. For my part, as I was saying in class, I try to spend a bit of relatively brainless time in the neighborhood every morning with the dogs. It's a happy time of day. Knowledge and lucidity aren't obstacles to happiness, but too much thinking can be.

Our author Monsieur Lenoir is still pushing us to the "Max": last time he urged maximum pleasure and reason, this time he invokes Andre Comte-Sponville for "maximum happiness in maximum lucidity." Is it always really so wise to push the pedal to the metal? Let up on the lucidity accelerator occasionally, I'd say. It better suits the rambling narrative of this Philosopher's Guide.

"Happiness is the awareness of an overall and enduring state of satisfaction in a meaningful existence founded on truth." I guess. Sometimes it's just a warm puppy, though. Awareness can be implicit and pre-verbal.

Satisfaction is a happy word, when coupled with the love of life. Matthieu Ricard's wish for wisdom, flourishing, and peace in every moment is lofty. But as we were saying last time, wasted moments are gone forever. Make a wish. A smart and willful wish, leading to well-chosen goals. Nietzsche's formula was for "a yes, a no, as straight line, a goal." He wasn't that happy, though, do you imagine?

Nor was Kant, I imagine.  "Full and complete happiness" may not exist on earth, but the promise of their attainment after death rings hollow to Epicureans, humanists, and others who think the "earth of things must resume its rights."
The really vital question for us all is, What is this world going to be? What is life eventually to make of itself? The centre of gravity of philosophy must therefore alter its place. The earth of things, long thrown into shadow by the glories of the upper ether, must resume its rights. Pragmatism
Deferred gratification is often a necessary condition of our happiness, but is deferred happiness ever a good idea?

Some more questions: Does illusory happiness interest you? Can you be happy in the absence of meaning and truth? Do you share Matthieu Ricard's "primary aspiration"? Does it set the bar too high? Do you know people who "lose themselves in a permanent hyperactivity, artificially filling the emptiness of their lives"? Is that a fair characterization, or an external view from an unsympathetic perspective? Is it your duty to make yourself worthy of happiness, to be as happy as possible, both, neither... or is talk of "duty" irrelevant to the question of happiness? Were Socrates and Jesus happy? Are martyrs happy, generally? Do you wish for a cause to die for?
==
It's the birthday of H.G. Wells (books by this author), born Herbert George in London (1866). He is the sci-fi writer most known for The Time Machine, The Invisible Man, and War of the Worlds. Wells wasn't the first to write about time travel or alien invasions, but his brand of sci-fi was uniquely realistic. He wanted to make the made-up science as believable as possible. Wells called this his "system of ideas" — today we would call it suspension of disbelief... and here's a nice Happiness poem for today, by Cousin Mary:
“If you suddenly and unexpectedly feel joy, don’t hesitate. Give in to it. There are plenty of lives and whole towns destroyed or about to be. We are not wise, and not very often kind. And much can never be redeemed. Still life has some possibility left. Perhaps this is its way of fighting back, that sometimes something happened better than all the riches or power in the world. It could be anything, but very likely you notice it in the instant when love begins. Anyway, that’s often the case. Anyway, whatever it is, don’t be afraid of its plenty. Joy is not made to be a crumb. (Don't Hesitate)”
 WA

Tuesday, September 19, 2017

Lenoir's Happiness

In Happiness today we begin Frederic Lenoir's Happiness: A Philosopher's Guide. In case there's any doubt, our author is quite French.




Many professional thinking persons are, unsurprisingly, convinced that a deep curiosity about the world and an unsettled awareness of our peculiar place in it are both prerequisite to living happily and well, and would agree that "it is essential to be aware of our happiness to be happy."

Or, if they're not convinced, they're nonetheless vocationally committed to pursuing inquiry as if they were. As James says so well in Varieties of Religious Experience, "philosophy lives in words" - and it's in words that philosophers must express and transact their curiosity and awareness - "but truth and fact well up into our lives in ways that exceed verbal formulation."

So, what's an honest philosopher to do with the realization that happiness may be visited upon us in moments of silence, meditation, and mute appreciation?

Well, he could admit perhaps that sometimes the pleasures of thinking about nothing (if not "NOTHING") and doing nothing may far exceed an intellectual's preconceptions as to the conditions of happiness. As in religion, sometimes a philosopher of happiness must defend experience against philosophy. That's one of my secular acts.

It's hard to dispute Montaigne's suggestion that happiness is amplified when we know and appreciate that we're happy. Clap your hands. Again, though, E.B. White poses the Thinking Man's perennial dilemma: savor the moment, or save the world? ("I arise in the morning torn between a desire to improve the world and a desire to enjoy the world. This makes it hard to plan the day.")

I vote "both," but don't ask me how. Knowing what you want is not the same as knowing how to get it. But we do know, don't we, that moments unsavored are lost? And that no one of us alone can be the Savior? (Who would ever take seriously a presidential candidate, for instance, who said only he could fix things? Deplorable!)

So my unsolicited advice is, guard and enjoy every moment you can. Saving the world is a longer-term project. When planning your day, be sure to leave room for some savoring moments. But also, as we mostly agreed last time (didn't we?): don't be an asshole in the pursuit of happiness. A little Buddhist self-abnegating cherry-picking might be a useful corrective here.

Again, I highly recommend Robert Wright's new book. "Don’t feel like you’re committing a felony-level violation of Buddhist dogma just because you think of yourself as being a self,” but also don't take yourself so seriously that you become indifferent to others' happiness as well as your own. “Ultimately, happiness comes down to choosing between the discomfort of becoming aware of your mental afflictions and the discomfort of being ruled by them.” So, awareness is a step on the path to potential enlightenment.

The Pleasure Principle may sound like Freudian flap-doodle to some, but if pleasure had no adaptive value it surely would have gone by the boards long ago. "The vigorous, the healthy, and the happy survive and multiply," let us hope.

Aristotle, on Lenoir's reading, endorses a life balancing "the maximum of pleasure with the maximum of reason." I'm uneasy about "maximum," but for rational animals such as we aspire to be, those surely must be the right constituent parts. The ratio of the mix might vary, animal to animal and person to person. Not all virtues are equally salient for each of us, some strike a more courageous or magnanimous or gentle note (etc.) - but do take note, there are many virtues available for our respective pursuits of excellence. With all due respect to the student who posted his view that the only real virtues involve deference to God and love for our neighbors, that's needlessly self-limiting.

I'm not familiar with Lenoir's "peasant-philosopher" Pierre Rahbi, but "happy sobriety" sounds Epicurean enough. "Necessary things are easy to attain," by comparison. Food and drink and shelter, once procured, ought to make fine cooking, beautiful clothes, a fancy home (etc.) less urgent, and power and honors entirely gratuitous. If pleasure really is the key to happiness, we ought to give more thought to what pleasures most conduce to lasting happiness, and ought to be prepared to agree with Epicurus that the best things in life are practically free.

Of course, Epicurus presumably never experienced the finest craft beer.

I'm definitely prepared to agree with sourpuss Schopenhauer that 90% of happiness depends on health. I'm surprised he said that. "Keep your health, your splendid health. It's better than all the truths in the firmament."

Meaning, again. Viktor Frankl and Sigmund Freud might agree that most of us are "truly happy only when our lives are pleasant and also have meaning." But is meaning an afterthought, or is it in fact the culmination of human-order pleasure?

Some questions: Do you ever wish you were less susceptible to living the examined life, a little less curious and aware and a bit more like Forrest Gump or Winnie the Pooh? Is there a danger of shrinking or crushing our happinesss, in the very process of observing and savoring ("amplifying") it? Is it generally true, as Darwin asserted, that in our world "the vigorous, healthy, and happy survive and multiply"? Do philosophers overrate the importance of reason and reflection in the pursuit of happiness? Do you espouse "mens sana in corpore sano"? Can you imagine surviving an ordeal like the holocaust or the Vietnam War (check out Ken Burns' new film) with your capacity for happiness intact?
==
Today is the birthday of essayist Roger Angell (books by this author), born in New York in 1920... His stepfather was E.B. White, author of Charlotte's Web... "It is foolish and childish, on the face of it, to affiliate ourselves with anything so insignificant and patently contrived and commercially exploitative as a professional sports team, and the amused superiority and icy scorn that the non-fan directs at the sports nut […] is understandable and almost unanswerable. Almost. What is left out of this calculation, it seems to me, is the business of caring — caring deeply and passionately, really caring — which is a capacity or an emotion that has almost gone out of our lives. […] It no longer matters so much what the caring is about, how frail or foolish is the object of that concern, as long as the feeling itself can be saved. Naïveté — the infantile and ignoble joy that sends a grown man or woman to dancing and shouting with joy in the middle of the night over the haphazardous flight of a distant ball — seems a small price to pay for such a gift."

Angell roots for the Mets, and doesn't get too discouraged when they lose. He thinks that rooting for a team that wins all the time is overrated, because you take it for granted and there's less drama in watching the game. He said, "Almost winning is almost the best. But you've got to win once in a while."

Angell wrote an essay about getting older in 2014 called "This Old Man," which he included in a book of essays of the same title. He writes about his own experience of changing physically and losing friends, and how society treats elderly people as if they're irrelevant. He describes a conversation where "There's a pause, and I chime in with a couple of sentences. The others look at me politely, then resume the talk exactly at the point where they've just left it. What? Hello? Didn't I just say something? Have I left the room? […] When I mention the phenomenon to anyone around my age, I get back nods and smiles. Yes, we're invisible. Honored, respected, even loved, but not quite worth listening to anymore. You've had your turn, Pops; now it's ours."

His wife, Carol, passed away shortly before he wrote the essay. She had told him, "If you haven't found someone else by a year after I'm gone, I'll come back and haunt you." Angell writes about how we look down on older people when they start dating again, as if we expect them to settle into the background of life and certainly not try anything new that's romantic or sexual. He writes: "But to hell with them and with all that, O.K.? Here's to you, old dears. You got this right, every one of you. Hook, line, and sinker; never mind the why or wherefore; somewhere in the night; love me forever, or at least until next week." WA

Thursday, September 7, 2017

Measured satisfaction

Two more very short chapters from Daniel Haybron today, on Life Satisfaction and Measuring Happiness. The former sounds slippery, the latter potentially too precise. But it might in fact be easier to measure slippery satisfaction, suitably specified, than elusive happiness. The title of Haybron's bigger book suggests that, to me: The Pursuit of Unhappiness: The Elusive Psychology of Well-Being.

Most of us would probably say our lives were going badly if we found ourselves in Moreese "Pop" Bickham's situation (as recounted on Story Corps) - thirty-seven years (fourteen on death row) in Louisiana's Angola Prison, for returning fire against the Klan Cops who tried to kill him. He said, on release, "I don't have one minute's regret. It was a glorious experience." He was "glad and happy and praising the Lord." I'm pretty sure I'd have responded differently. Good for him?

Wonder how he'd rate his life on a scale of 1 to 10, and whether it matters or is simply arbitrary. If you think you're a 10, shouldn't you be happier (more content, more satisfied, more something) in some subjective sense than if you think you're a 4? Surely.

The numbers may not add up, certainly may not nail happiness down with anything like the precision they imply, but the Eulogy Standard seems helpful here. What will they say aboutyour life, at your funeral? Wouldn't you like to be there to find out? By this standard it seems plausible to think "most people actually have good lives" whether they know it or not.

So one of the takeaways today seems to be that very rough and approximate ballpark estimations of happiness are good enough, in terms of their practical utility. People understate their happiness on rainy days (except for the perverse people who say they always prefer inclement weather because it makes the indoors that much more appealing). Unemployed people tend to be less happy. Etc. These generally reliable generalizations remind us not to waste the good days, and not to be unemployed. Valuable reminders, those.

If you have a slight preponderance of positive over negative emotional states, are you (slightly) happy? Haybron doesn't think so. Your happiness should not be a close call, he suggests. But I don't know, maybe we ought to just take what we can get and be grateful for it. Wasn't that Pop Bickham's message? Start slight if you must, and work from there, if the glass is only 5/8 full.

By the way, which face on the scale (p.47) is yours today?
Image result for faces scale
Can you believe this guy's parting words were that he'd had a wonderful life? He did have, but rarely let his face know it. Or his sister's house.
Image result for wittgenstein

Considering suicide is one thing, what Camus called life's ultimate philosophical question, but acutally contemplating it is something else, I'd have said. The stats we'll consider are sobering. Hoping we don't echo them, in our Happy class.

I disagree with Camus's emphasis, I'd say the more pressing question for most of us is whether we're having wonderful lives, not whether we're thinking about ending them. But of course, George Bailey faced both.

Image result for it's a wonderful life

==
On this day in 1927, a 21-year-old inventor named Philo T. Farnsworth achieved the first fully electronic television system. He successfully transmitted an image through the purely electronic means of a device he called an “image dissector” (the first television camera tube). He’d been dreaming of this day since he was a 13-year-old farm boy, when he became inspired by the series of lines emanating from the back-and-forth motion used to plow a field. Farnsworth was a diligent young inventor: he converted his family’s home appliances to electric power and won a national contest with his invention of a tamper-proof lock...

Today is the birthday of American jazz musician Sonny Rollins in New York City (1930). Rollins plays the tenor saxophone and is considered one of the finest jazz musicians in history. He favors long, experimental improvisation when he plays, especially during live concerts. He once said: “I’m not supposed to be playing, the music is supposed to be playing me. I’m just supposed to be standing there with the horn, moving my fingers. The music is supposed to be coming through me; that’s when it’s really happening.”

...Rollins credits his study of Kabbalah, Buddhism, Indian philosophy, and yoga for his music... I’ve got a gift, a musical gift, fine. But I want to be a human being, a good human being. I need to always express that to young students. Everybody can have a gift. That’s a gift. But then we have to be good human beings. So that’s what it’s all about.”

Thursday, August 31, 2017

"Life is good"

So said the Amazonian Piraha people, according to Daniel Everett, before it became a popular marketing slogan.

Image result for life is good

Happiness (the class) begins today with Daniel Haybron's Very Short Introduction, which includes that epigramatic reference to the Pirahas and then tells us that Socrates - so often exalted as a paradigmatically happy man, right up until the hemlock kicked in, in his 70th year - "didn't miss out on a thing." Well, he missed out on his 71st. Life might have been better, certainly longer.

Was Socrates happier than the average college student? "You might think the typical college student lives in a state of bliss," with minimal obligations and maximal opportunities to ruminate, socialize, and party, but apparently that would be wrong. How many of them are living the examined life? Ignorance is perhaps not bliss, after all? But what about enlightened Socratic ignorance? Either way, American students are apparently less happy than we thought.

Panama is most blissful, evidently. Or was. More recent results point elsewhere. Denmark? Iceland? (I think I recall Eric Weiner's Geography of Bliss giving them high marks.)

One way to chart our happiness index is to ask what's on your bucket list. Another: what's not on your deathbed list of things you just have to do one more time. Maybe not "another peck at the mobile phone, or one more trip to the mall." Maybe you won't wish you'd bought more crap.

"What sort of life ultimately benefits a person," wondered Aristotle. What, not shopping or iPhoning? How many of us can even imagine how bizarre those activities would seem to an old Greek philosopher?

A young Intro student yesterday told me it was his impression that philosophy was mostly about pondering and pontificating on our feelings. But Haybron quickly withdraws feeling theories from the field, in favor of "life satisfaction." But don't confuse that with "subjective well-being," a catch-all of psychologism he says we must confuse with our real quarry.

Has there really never been a better time to be alive? I wouldn't have said the first decade of this millennium was the best ever, but it depends on the yardstick. Steven Pinker's Better Angels makes the case for our good luck.

Many indigenous peoples say the only thing they envy about the western industrial lifestyle is healthcare (and we know how fraught that is). William James told his friend Schiller to "keep your health, your splendid health - it's worth all the truths in the firmament." Hard not to agree, especially after a bout with serious illness. If you've not experienced that, by the time you reach "a certain age," you're even luckier than most.

Haybron says "we need a theory - a definition - of happiness." Do we? What do you mean, we? We philosophers? We authors? We moderns? We shoppers and social media fanatics? Why can't we be happily undefined and atheoretical? Presumably because the absence of a good theoretical framework leaves us in the wrong "state of mind." 

Happiness is a state of mind, for sure, but it's even more a state of experience and expectation. No?
==
On this day in 1837, Ralph Waldo Emerson delivered his famous "American Scholar" address to the Phi Beta Kappa Society at Harvard (books by this author). He told the students to think for themselves rather than absorb thought, to create rather than repeat, and not to look to Europe for cultural models... 

It's the birthday of Armenian-American writer William Saroyan (books by this author), born in Fresno, California (1908). His parents were recent refugees from the Turkish massacres in Armenia. His father died when William was three. Saroyan's mother, placed her children in the Fred Finch Orphanage in Oakland, California. Saroyan spent five years there before his mother was able to claim him... Towards the end of his life and dying of prostate cancer, he called the Associated Press to give a statement to be released posthumously. The statement was: "Everybody has got to die, but I have always believed an exception would be made in my case. Now what?"

And it's the birthday of Maria Montessori (books by this author), born on this day in Chiaravalle, Italy (1870)... She believed that children were not blank slates, but that they each had inherent, individual gifts. It was a teacher's job to help children find these gifts, rather than dictating what a child should know. She emphasized independence, self-directed learning, and learning from peers. Children were encouraged to make decisions. She was the first educator to use child-sized tables and chairs in the classroom. WA