Delight Springs

Monday, March 17, 2014

Montaigne, Descartes, Pascal, Rorty

We're back from Spring Break today, in CoPhi, first with the last group report presentations (postponed by our slight Snow Day before the break); then, Descartes (& Grayling on Descartes), Montaigne (& Bakewell on How to Live acc'ing to M), Pascal, and Romano on Richard Rorty. Three old French philosophers and one recent American. Only one of them (Descartes) thought we could truly know anything, but even he admitted he wasn't entirely sure life is not a dream. (First day back has its dream-like aspect, doesn't it?)

That's a bit misleading. None of them was an all-devouring Pyrrhonian, though  Montaigne had his moments. He and Rorty in particular were really taking issue with unreasonably high expectations for what we call knowledge. Lower those, and we'll know more than enough. In any event we know plenty that can't be "known" and (as Mark Twain put it) more that just ain't so. 



One other thing we know is the historical timeline. Montaigne comes first, but since I always introduce him as the anti-Descartes he rarely gets top billing. The late Robert Solomon did the same thing. Not fair, for a guy who gave us the essay and (as Sarah Bakewell says) is so much "fun" to read. Unlike Descartes he was a true skeptic (again though, not so far over the cliff as Pyrrho) and "quite happy to live with that." His slogan was Que sçais-je?

Montaigne inscribed the beams of his study with many of his favorite quotes, including "nothing human is foreign to me" and "the only certainty is that nothing is certain."

 [Montaigne @dawn... M on Self-esteem (deB)... M quotes... M's beam inscriptions... M "In Our Time" (BBC)...M's tower...M's Essays]



Rene Descartes, not at all (Pythons notwithstanding) a "drunken fart," simply wanted to know what he could know for certain. His skepticism was methodological, his goal was indubitable certainty. This, he thought, would serve the new science well. He misunderstood the self-correcting, probabilistic, fallibilistic nature of empirical reasoning. But most philosophers still think it’s worth wondering: how do you know you’re not dreaming, not being deceived by a demon or by your senses, not mistaking your own essential nature?

Still, cogito ergo sum overrates intellect. You don’t have to think, to demonstrate your existence. You just have to do something… even, as an old grad school pal used to say, if it’s wrong.



I usually think of Charles Sanders Peirce as Descartes’ most practical critic, and I agree with him that a contrived and methodological doubt is not the best starting place in philosophy.

But it occurs to me that an even more practical alternative to what I consider the misguided Cartesian quest for certainty is old Ben Franklin’s Poore Richard. His is not armchair wisdom, it comes straight from the accumulated experience of the folk. Some of that “common sense” is too common, but plenty is dead-on. “Early to bed, early to rise…” has definitely worked for me.

Still, says Grayling, "we may disagree with Descartes that the right place to start is with the private data of consciousness" rather than the shared world of language and common experience; but even if he was wrong he was "powerfully, interestingly, and importantly wrong."

There’s much more to Blaise Pascal than his famous Wager [SEP], besides his mathematics and "Pascaline," his proto-computer, there are all those thoughts (Pensees) and there’s also his antipathy for his fellow  philosophe Francais, Montaigne. I usually compare-&-contrast Montaigne and Descartes, so this makes for a nice new menage a trois (without an accent). Blaise is hostile to both Rene and Michel but is a cautious gambler, finding Descartes’ God too antiseptic and too, well, philosophical. And he finds Montaigne a self-absorbed, trivia-mongering potty-mouth.

But Montaigne would not at all disagree that “the heart has its reasons which reason knows not.” And isn’t it funny to think of Descartes philosophizing in his hypothetical armchair, asking if his fire and his body (etc.) are real, pretending to speculate that all the world and its philosophical problems might be figments of his solipsistic or dreamy or demon-instigated imagination? And then funnier still to come across this quote from Pascal: “All of humanity’s problems stem from man’s inability to sit quietly in a room alone.”  But look what happens when a philosopher sits quietly in a room alone: you get the Meditations!
Pascal also said
“Truth is so obscure in these times, and falsehood so established, that, unless we love the truth, we cannot know it.” And “It is man’s natural sickness to believe that he possesses the Truth.”
And
“There are two equally dangerous extremes: to exclude reason, to admit nothing but reason.”
And
“The nature of man is wholly natural, omne animal. There is nothing he may not make natural; there is nothing natural he may not lose.”*
And
“The weather and my mood have little connection. I have my foggy and my fine days within me…” [Or as Jimmy Buffett says, carry the weather with you.]
And all military veterans especially should appreciate this one:
“Can anything be stupider than that a man has the right to kill me because he lives on the other side of a river and his ruler has a quarrel with mine, though I have not quarrelled with him?”
And this will be an epigraph for my Philosophy Walks (or its sequel Philosophy Rides):
“Our nature lies in movement; complete calm is death.”

But Pascal does finally blow the big game of life, for betting too heavily on self-interest. He’s obsessed with “saving [his] own soul at all costs.” That’s a losing proposition.

[*That statement about us being "omne animal" sounded flattering, to me, being a philosophical naturalist and a friend to animals. But later epigraphs indicate Pascal's platonist perfectionism and his derogatory attitude towards humanity and its natural condition. Without God's grace, he writes, we are "like unto the brute beasts." He doesn't seem pleased about that, but I'm with Walt Whitman: "I think I could turn and live with animals, they're so placid and self contain'd... They do not sweat and whine about their condition... They do not make me sick discussing their duty to God..."]

Julia Sweeney, donning her no-god glasses, gets to the nub of what’s wrong with Pascal’s Wager:
So how can I come up against this biggest question, the ultimate question, “Do I really believe in a personal God,” and then turn away from the evidence? How can I believe, just because I want to? How will I have any respect for myself if I did that?
I thought of Pascal’s Wager. Pascal argued that it’s better to bet there is a God, because if you’re wrong there’s nothing to lose, but if there is, you win an eternity in heaven. But I can’t force myself to believe, just in case it turns out to be true. The God I’ve been praying to knows what I think, he doesn’t just make sure I show up for church. How could I possibly pretend to believe? I might convince other people, but surely not God.

And probably not Richard Rorty, for whom philosophy is not about nailing down the unequivocal Truth but rather continuing the never-concluding Conversation of humankind. 

Rorty was the most controversial philosopher on the scene back when I began grad school, having just published his brilliantly and infuriatingly iconoclastic Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature. Everybody had to have a view on it, and on his view that philosophy's long quest to represent "external reality" accurately was a waste of time we were free to give up. We could ditch our "comic" efforts "to guarantee this and clarify that." 

Philosophers get attention only when they appear to be doing something sinister--corrupting the youth, undermining the foundations of civilization, sneering at all we hold dear. The rest of the time everybody assumes that they are hard at work somewhere down in the sub-basement, keeping those foundations in good repair. Nobody much cares what brand of intellectual duct tape is being used.
My current position, after several oscillations, has settled at last into the earnest wish that more philosophers wrote as wittily and as well as he did. Almost none do. Did he get pragmatism and truth right? I guess that's what he'd call a duct tape question.

Friday, March 7, 2014

Don't miss the boat

Our final Bioethics report took us back to the lifeboat.


Group 3's creative take on this scenario was to hitch it to an even more fanciful and perilous lifeboat and ask if survival might require us to jettison not only some of our fellow castaways but also the more refined and reflective aspects of our selves. 


A compelling discussion of life, Pi, instinct and reason, the power of storytelling, the value of religion, and much more ensued. Some of us had a lot to say. I suppose my biggest takeaway, aside from a desire to read the novel and really watch the film, is a sense that utilitarian-style lifeboat ethics is at best an interesting academic exercise. But if I ever find myself in a boat with a tiger, real or invented, I'll need more than that to survive. In Campbell's lifeboat, I hope I'd not be tempted to ditch Granny, the young woman, or the baby in the name of utility alone. This story's moral, for me, is that there's a lot more to life than merely living.

In A&P we heard about Maiya's conversion to Spinozism, William's logical deconstruction of theism, Colton's response to the problem of evil, Devin's research and historically-rooted  reflections on Atheist Church (Sunday Assembly, School of Life etc.), and Rachel's favorite Good Book scripture, Wisdom 10.5-8. Back in the boat:
Consider when, on a voyage, your ship is anchored; if you go on shore to get 
water you may amuse yourself along the way with picking up a shellsh. 6. 
However, your attention must also be towards the ship, waiting for the captain to 
call you on board; 7. For when he does so, you must immediately leave all these things, otherwise you will miss the ship as it sails. 8. So it is with life...
Indeed. Gather ye rosebuds and shellfish, but remember: the nectar is in the journey.

And so I'm off to Memphis. Happy Spring Break!

Thursday, March 6, 2014

Badly broken

Reports from Groups 2 yesterday, in both CoPhi classes, managed to arrive at much the same conclusion (or fulfill the same premise): villainy can be attractive, sometimes even heroic. The world is not black or white, for Walter White or Batman's nemeses or anyone. Those who would reduce virtue and propriety to a set of invariable rules, or align morality and ethics with law and convention, are trying to simplify something inherently complicated.

I agree, in principle. We must live pragmatically and flexibly, not rigidly rule-bound, and always ask ourselves if doing the right thing is the right thing to do. When we return from Spring Break we'll take that issue up with Immanuel Kant, J.S. Mill, and of course Willy James.

But...

If I got a terminal diagnosis tomorrow, and if my particular area of academic expertise happened to be as illicitly lucrative as chemistry or a comic book superpower might be in the "real world," I'm still pretty confident I'd not turn to a life of killing and crime. And if I did, I'd definitely not feel "authenticated" or self-reliant or honest.

Walter White may have been a bland and decent guy victimized more by circumstance and bad luck than by a bad character, catching bad breaks before choosing to break bad. But make no mistake, he made bad choices. He's no Existential Hero, no Sisyphus, no Ubermensch, though I do now understand why his story made such compelling television theater.


 Anyone inclinced to glamorize or romanticize meth-making as a lifestyle alternative for free spirits and autonomous revaluators of value needs to read real-life stories like those recounted recently in the newspaper. These are choices that ruin lives and subvert freedom. Ask the woman from Grundy County  who had it all blow up in her face. Literally.

Sorry, btw, about that Spoiler at the beginning late yesterday. But as a critic wrote,
When you give your lead character a terminal illness, usher him into the underworld and embroil him in ever bolder and more ambitious criminal plans, you create a man who is rushing toward the ultimate change — from being alive to being dead. Walter White is surely the most doomed character on television...
Yes, he was. That's not the kind of change anyone should want to rush. Or push for.



Wednesday, March 5, 2014

Animal testing and letting go

"Light freezing fog" out there this morning, but we're promised a balmy 50 degree day later. Can Spring be far? Or Spring Break? We could sure use one.

In Bioethics yesterday, a report on Animal Testing. "Out of sight, out of mind," was Group 2's consensus view of our species' general attitude toward others. Gratuitous harm perpetrated on defenseless animals in the name of human convenience and safety is regrettable, but on the other hand we all love a bargain. We'd rather not commit to spending a few cents more on food and cosmetics (etc.) to signal a humanitarian consumer revolt, if we're being honest. Painfully honest. But we're not the ones bearing the pain.

Googling around on the topic, I came across an old but golden essay by my old ETSU colleague Hugh LaFollette.
Biomedical experimentation on animals is justified, researchers say, because of its enormous benefits to human beings. Sure animals die and suffer, but that is morally insignificant when compared to experimentation's spectacular payoffs. As Carl Cohen, a leading philosophical apologist for vivisection, writes: 'When balancing the pleasures and pains resulting from the use of animals in research, we must not fail to place on the scales the terrible pains that would have resulted, would be suffered now, and would long continue had animals not been used. Every disease eliminated, every vaccine developed,... indeed, virtually every modern medical therapy is due, in part or in whole, to experimentation using animals.
Hugh goes on to challenge this view, very effectively I think. He was a terrific vegan chef, I recall. That's a skill we all ought to develop, maybe, or (minimally) support?

And did you see the new report on how bad a diet high in protein derived from animal fat can be for you? Worse than a pack a day. Older Daughter's coming home for Spring Break, just in time to take me out to Woodlands' for some Indian vegetarian.

(I seem to have strayed from animal testing to animal eating... either way, it's hard to wash away the blood and clear the conscience. Or it should be.)

In A&P, it was great to hear from some of the less voluble voices in our class. Group 2 reported on Bill Maher, Tim Minchin, nihilism and more. Dustin confessed his God Delusion conversion, and compiled a helpful list of female free-thinkers, just in case anyone doubts their existence.

And that's all the excuse I need to air my favorite former Roman Catholic SNL cast member from Spokane.


00:00 - There Is No Santa Claus
07:36 - The Mormon Boys Arrive
14:59 - My Religious History In A Nutshell
17:47 - I Wish I Were A Nun
23:32 - I Rededicate Myself To The Church
27:48 - Sodom & Gomorrah; Abraham & Issac
32:47 - The Ten Commandments
36:46 - The New Testament
41:38 - St. Paul & The Book Of Revelation
45:34 - Psychologically True
48:21 - Jesus Suffered, But So Did A Lot Of People
50:54 - Father Tom Blesses Me & I Get Out Of There
54:42 - I Begin To Drift East, Spiritually Speaking
1:00:37 - God Is Nature; The Galapagos
1:03:37 - Sister Charatina's Theory Of Evolution
1:08:05 - God Is Love
1:12:39 - Deepak
1:16:09 - I'm Becoming So Cantankerous
1:18:42 - How The Mind Works
1:22:10 - Intelligent Design
1:28:03 - What If It's True
1:34:47 - Good-Bye To God
1:38:24 - So, I'm Just Another Animal
1:42:49 - Mom & Dad Freak
1:50:11 - Mulan Arrives & Dad Is Sick
1:55:42 - A Funeral
2:02:04 - More Mormon Boys

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

Safe at home

It was the rarest of March days in middle Tennessee, with trace amounts of snow and ice shutting down our school. First day of canceled classes since 2010, I'm told.

Spent some of our sn'ice day, the dogs and I, huddled around the Earth Stove out back, listening to Grapefruit and Cactus League games via the MLB app and plotting my contribution to the impending annual Baseball in Literature & Culture conference. Our version of Hot Stove League, in this middling zone. Next year, Older Daughter and I have decided, we're spending our Spring Break down there.

Prompted by the Nashville Sounds' recent announcement that they're going home next season to their revered ancestral digs near the state capitol at Sulphur Dell (as renamed in 1908 by legendary sportswriter and Murfreesboro native Grantland Rice, from the less fetching "Sulphur Springs Bottom") I'm working up a little talk on baseball's perennial theme: completing the circuit and heading for home.

Where to begin? Well, first we'll review the storied past. The old Nashville Vols were the Dell's last occupants, closing it down 50 years ago, before the quirky park (with its uniquely short-and-sloping right field) was finally demolished later in the '60s. It was at that time the oldest park in the land, having hosted professional play (including Negro League teams) since 1870.

The way it was, and the way they promise it will be:





Then, some personal and sentimental reminiscences about Herschel Greer Stadium. My first game in Nashville was there, seated behind a rope in the outfield. The place has become kind of a dump, frankly, and it's past time for it to be left behind; but that won't hold back the flood of memories sure to come when we attend our last game there, this summer.

And then of course, after that look over the shoulder while rounding 2d, we'll want to pick up the 3d base coach and begin anticipating a new history in the new place.

Did some of my "research" yesterday, with John Feinstein's Where Nobody Knows Your Name, quoting an old pitcher who staged an improbable comeback ("sometimes going full circle in life isn't a good thing) and even more improbably A Brit at the Ballpark (Englishman Peter Taylor sets out to round 'em all and attend professional baseball in all 50 states in a single summer season). I'll have to squeeze in some George Carlin on the significance of "home" in baseball (there's nothing like it in football), and Carl Sagan ("human beings born ultimately of the stars have begun their long voyage home"), and Jennifer Hecht on hanging signs on trees and considering the "forest" home, and T.S. Eliot on returning to the place whence we came and knowing it at last...

The ice is slowly melting this morning. Guess we'd better get on back to school.

Friday, February 28, 2014

Bodies ascending

More solid group reports yesterday, and another whole week of them lies ahead in the run-up to Spring Break. Have to admit: it's getting better! (BTW: What do you mean you don't "get" the Beatles, William?)

Group 1 in Bioethics: you guys still need a name. How about The Stiffs? After your report topic, not your fluid presentation. Who knew the ethics of mortal disposition could be so engaging? Home Run! But I can't believe none of you had ever heard of The Splendid Splinter. Now there's a prime candidate for thawing and reassembly in the year 2525, if the national pastime is still alive.


Our culture does not do a great job of facing death squarely, hence our general uneasiness with this subject.  But medical professionals have to become comfortable with it, or at least familiar. I'm glad we spent some class time doing that. (And sorry I couldn't resist some obvious puns before we finished, like "kicking a dead horse" etc.)

Some might think the subject of Faith was a dead horse, but Group 1 in A&P kicked it around with novelty and panache. 

They had much of the faith spectrum covered, from Jamey's W.K. Clifford view ("it's wrong to believe without evidence") to Jon's pragmatic pluralism to the implied faith in belief (whether secular or woo-ey) that many of them seemed to endorse. (Still not sure what to make of that "embarrassing" old Princeton engineering study of mind's mysterious anomalies, Josh, but as Dean would say: it gives me pause.)

One perspective remained unaddressed, unless I missed it: John Dewey's "common faith"-a faith in as-yet-unachieved human and humane ideals for which we may work, rather than in allegedly actual (but evidentially unsupported) supernatural realities we may merely ponder and worship.

“Men have gone on to build up vast intellectual schemes, philosophies, and theologies, to prove that ideals are not real as ideals but as antecedently existing actualities. They have failed to see that in converting moral realities into matters of intellectual assent they have evinced lack of moral faith. Faith that something should be in existence as far as lies in our power is changed into the intellectual belief that it is already in existence. When physical existence does not bear out the assertion, the physical is subtly changed into the metaphysical. In this way, moral faith has been inextricably tied up with intellectual beliefs about the supernatural.” John Dewey, A Common Faith
That's one of the many versions of humanist faith, which rejects arbitrary faith, authority, and revelation, but affirms humanity and its aspirations for life. The gap between reality and the achievement of our dreams is a standing invitation to move onward into the fog.

I for one remain confident and hopeful (though uncertain) that we as a species will get to the promised land at the top of the stairs, though we cannot see them all from here. Yet.



Thursday, February 27, 2014

Full of possibilities

Strong reports yesterday from Team Why Not on Calvin & Hobbes, and the Philosoraptors on Epicureanism. "Have No Fear" might be the best summary takeaway from both, though of course fear can be your friend when it's not purely groundless. I still contend that our heroes' real-life namesakes (John & Thomas) were committed to philosophies shorn of real possibility: reductive materialism, authoritarianism, determinism, predestination. (John Calvin said if we're damned we're damned, and if not we're just undeservedly lucky. Even innocent little newborns deserve whatever hellfire they may get?! Nothing sweet and cuddly there.)

But, whatever gets us out and exploring. The last C&H ran during the holiday season of Older Daughter's birth, when she was just two months old. There was no room in my heart, in those magical days, for hellfire and damnation. Nor in Bill Watterson's either, I think. And look: he's back!

Calvin and Hobbes

Wednesday, February 26, 2014

The days are just packed


Busy day yesterday!
First an unexpectedly inspiring morning tour of Nashville's Hillsboro High, delightedly abuzz with enthusiastic teachers and engaged students. Of course they wouldn't showcase the snoozers, but all the same it was an impressive display of public education that seems to be working. The young science guy, a Vandy Ph.D., was spilling over with excitement for his vocation, his mission to hook kids on the magic of reality. 
Similarly energized was the multimedia & communicatrions specialist ("she used to work at CNN") and the International Baccalaureate humanities instructor who teaches an interdisciplinary course called Theory of Knowledge ("we try to get students excited about the questions"). And we met a purpose-driven kid having fun working on stage design ("it's what I want to do with my life") for the upcoming production of Seussical. That was not my High School. Go Burros! 

Then, a brisk refocusing pre-class stroll around the grounds of the antebellum mansion at Oaklands (down the street from MTSU), setting up animated discussion in Bioethics and Atheism.



Then, heading straight out into rush hour after class in a slightly delusional attempt to arrive at Ensworth High School in time to catch Younger Daughter's first softball action of the season, I rediscovered that Old Hickory Boulevard is no place to be during drive time. But I did eventually arrive in time to see my favorite pitcher/shortstop field her position before a gorgeous setting sun.

And then it was off again to Vandy for David Wood's Berry Lecture on Kierkegaard and Nietzsche. Made me stronger. (Stay tuned for info on David's upcoming Lyceum Lecture at MTSU on April 11.)


Made it home in time to say good night, and to begin anticipating today's eagerly awaited CoPhi group presentations on Epicurus and Calvin & Hobbes.

No water balloons, but life is good.

Tuesday, February 25, 2014

Venter's meaning, Rosenberg's nihilism

Craig Venter's next chapters in Life at Light Speed, in Bioethics, continue to limn "the new field of the biochemistry of information" and the stellar history of the bacteriophage phi X 174, "the first to have its genome artificially copied and activated." It's a long way from the sewers of Paris, where 174 first surfaced.

There's a lot of blow-by-blow technical stuff in these chapters about how Venter's team went about their project of digitizing and synthesizing DNA. Much of it eludes me.

But I perked up and took notice when Arthur Caplan came on stage and went to work with a team of bioethicists to produce the report eventually published in Science: "Ethical Considerations in Synthesizing a Minimal Genome."

"The only reason for ethics to lag behind this line of research is if we choose to allow it to do so." And we may. But isn't it empowering to be granted a choice, still?

"It is disturbing that current regulatory methods provide little if any oversight of these technologies." Indeed.

Venter seems miffed that the report pondered "the impact of reductionist science on 'the meaning and origin of life'" without first having defined "life." But we know what life is, it's what happens while you're making other plans. Some of us worry that our ability to make any plans at all, ever again, is at risk with this research. He thinks the greater risk lies in not doing the research.
“How we understand our own selves, and how we work with our DNA software has implications that will affect everything from vaccine development, to new approaches to antibiotics, new sources of food, new sources of chemicals, even potentially new sources of energy. Food will be manufactured — it won’t be grown in fields — in 50 years... If we don’t do the experiments, if we don’t try and use this new knowledge to solve some of the problems of poverty, of hunger, of disease, it’s going to be a pretty nasty world in 50 years, with 4 billion people, three times more than when I was born. But I’m an optimist. I think we have at hand tools that humanity has never had before, the tools to truly have control over nature, and if we use those wisely — and we use them — the future could be pretty bright.” Venter on the meaning of life... TED... May '10... Caplan at Chautauqua
In a somewhat less sanguine mood in 2010, a decade after his group's initial report, Caplan told the Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues:
I want to persuade you that there are deeper philosophical concerns that, while perhaps harder to pinpoint, underlie some of the disquiet about the field of synthetic biology... As we have seen with many other breakthroughs in the biomedical sciences ranging from cloning to the reproductive technologies to stem cell research, more is involved in evincing public concerns about new directions in science than worries about safety... Learning to live in a world where life has been shown by science to be the product of material forces subject to human control will likely prove for many a challenge to rival worries about safety.
New Directions: The Ethics of Synthetic Biology and Emerging Technologies-Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues, December 2010...Statement from JCV

In Alex Rosenberg's Atheist's Guide to Reality, in A&P, we'll consider the "bad news" that nihilism is true and the "good news" that nihilists are nice as can be. They're not moral relativists, they're not moral skeptics, they're not Karamazovian anarchists who think everything's permitted. They just don't think there are objectively, demonstrably "right" answers to life's persistent questions. We can't reasonably hope to find "the right answers," just answers we like. And as always, we still can ply our powers of persuasion to our hearts' content.

Nice. Who could ask for anything more? Well, you could ask...

In a Rortian mood, I'm frequently inclined to agree with Rosenberg about this. I just wouldn't call it nihilism, which seems needlessly alarmist and provocative.

The problem with Rosenberg's version of godless scientism, in this case, is not (as he suggests) that it saps life of meaning and leaves us nothing to roll out of bed for. The problem is that it does not seem to allow for the personal determination of meaning and purpose.

The real bugbear in the vicinity is humanism, not scientism. The way to tame it is not by insisting on science as exhaustively expressive of all meaning and purpose, but by simply noting that various humans have found various meanings and purposes gratifying, motivating, and fulfilling. Not nihil, not "nothing."

"Scientism can't avoid nihilism." Sure it can: just emulate humanism's plurality of meanings and purposes, don't try to express everything in a scientific idiom. "Not everything worth expressing can or should be expressed scientifically." Let a hundred or a thousand vocabularies bloom, and see how quickly the specter of nihilism vanishes.