Delight Springs

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Spirituality naturalized

In Bioethics we're taking a study-and-reflection day, between texts. We'll recap Campbell's Basics, look at some links, work on group reports, and get ready for next week's commencement of Life at the Speed of Light. Sounds ambitious. Are we trying to play Craig Venter?

start

Speaking of Godlessness, today in A&P we'll put The Really Hard Problem of meaning for atheist-materialists behind us. There's an excellent discussion of the issue in Julian Baggini's very short introduction to Atheism, a very good little book we read two years ago inA&P.  His "heathen manifesto" echoes Owen Flanagan on many points. 
Many people do not understand that it is possible to lead a meaningful, happy life as a heathen, but we maintain that it is and can point to any number of atheist philosophers and thinkers who have explained why this is so. But such meaning and contentment does not inevitably follow from becoming a heathen. Ours is a universe without guarantees of redemption or salvation and sometimes people have terrible lives or do terrible things and thrive. On such occasions, we have no consolation. That is the dark side of accepting the truth, and we are prepared to acknowledge it. We are heathens because we value living in the truth. But that does not mean that we pretend that always makes life easy or us happy. If the evidence were to show that religious people are happier and healthier than us, we would not see that as any reason to give up our convictions.

Flanagan defends the expressive rights of the religious, but insists that assertion be more circumspect and evidence-driven. His final paragraph on naturalized spirituality and transcendence points us constructively towards our next texts, beginning with his fellow Blue Devil Alex Rosenberg's Atheist's Guide to Reality and proceeding to Christopher Hitchens' Mortality and Carl Sagan's Varieties of Scientific Experience. 
Happiness, flourishing, and meaning reside in the vicinity of embodying ideals of the human good that connect me to a goal beyond my own personal desires, and that are inclusive of all actual and future persons (possibly of all sentient beings)...
It's a big, meaningful, natural cosmos, we're at home in it, and that's something to sing about. How much more spiritual do we need to get?

Well, we could pull up a pew at the School of Life or (closer to home) Sunday Assembly.

Monday, February 10, 2014

A skeptic and a hedonist at the APA

Maybe throw in a stoic or a cynic and we'll have the perfect set-up for a classic-cliche joke. But, no need. The APA is always funny, whatever the attendance.

In CoPhi today it's Pyrrho the deep skeptic,  Epicurus the hedonist (though applying that label to him indiscriminately, as his critics did and do, can be misleading) and seeker of simple pleasures and happiness; and APA the behemoth that tried to eat philosophy. 

No Philosophy Bites on our syllabus today, but here's an interesting discussion of skepticism (or scepticism, as the Brits have it) from the excellent BBC4 program "In Our Time." And with Valentine's Day approaching, you may want to check out their recent show on Plato's Symposium, and an earlier one on the Philosophy of Love. And Epicureanism. 

Speaking of V'day, remember to bring cake and candy, or biscuits and jam, for teacher on Thursday (or Wednesday). And for everybody else too, of course. Exams are scheduled, but that's no reason to postpone a party. (Did you see Paul and Ringo in the Ed Sullivan theater last night?) Thanks to Older Daughter for bringing herself and John Green for a pre-V'day celebration this weekend. He rightly notes in his Fault in Our Stars epigraph that water and time dissolve everything. Meanwhile, as Mr. Emerson said, the days are gods. Still crazy after all these years.

I'm also still accepting housewarming gifts for my new office. But, back to the set-up for that philosophy joke:

What an amusing fantasy mental image to visualize: toga-clad old Greek and Roman wisdom-seekers roaming the Baltimore or Boston or Atlanta Marriott, amidst all those smoldering pocketed pipes and raggedy patched tweeds and all that careerist angst at the American Philosophical Association's Eastern Division meeting in December. I'd skip a post-Xmas visit with the family in St. Louis, to see that. 


Actually I did attend a Central Division APA at the St. Louis downtown Marriott back in the '80s. (It was the Whitey Herzog era, "What a Team/What a Town/What a Time!" booster banners dotted the streets. Better red than dead, they were.) Spotted no obviously-Pyrrhonic skeptics or Epicurean hedonists. But, philosophers behaving badly, being obtuse about credit card swipes and obnoxious about "the fine points of life?" Oh yes indeed. 


I'm not a big fan of professional philosophy conferences, though I've done my share of APAs and TPAs and SAAPs etc. They're necessary for "networking" and maintaining professional relationships and collegial friendships. But skype and other new communications technologies have begun to supplant the demeaning   job "meatmarket" function of these conferences. Good riddance. 


On the other hand, I do cherish the bizarre memory of strolling through a Vegas casino en route to Bill McKibben's SAAP keynote on the environment in 2000. Euguene, Oregon. Lexington, Kentucky. Milwaukee. New Jersey. College Station. Bakersfield. I've been everywhere, man...


Well, Carlin Romano's point is that the time has come to "think differently and more inclusively" about philosophy in America. It's not just for us card-carrying APA pros anymore. Thankfully so.


Today's AtP reading concludes at the outset of a discussion of the ideas of political philosopher Michael Walzer (Just and Unjust Wars et al), who says our national identity (in contrast to most nations) is largely invented rather than inherited. The Constitution itself, and the Constitution Day public reading thereof which I proudly participated in, on our campus back in the Fall, is a prime example of what he means.


I caught Walzer on the radio recently. He argued for a U.S. military strike in Syria. (I hope nobody in Washington in still seriously contemplating that. As they might have sung at the Beatlefest last night, give peace a chance. All I'm sayin'.) What a pleasant surprise, for a change, to find our leaders apparently opting to give diplomacy and peace a chance before letting the bombs fly. On the other hand, he's right: we can't afford to turn a blind eye to children being murdered, anywhere. The whole world should be watching.



Back to Pyrrho and Epicurus... but first a quick follow-up on Plato and Aristotle. Check out this version of School of Athens.

As for Aristotle’s eudaimonia, in some ways it anticipated Epicurus’s garden and what Jennifer Michael Hecht calls “graceful-life philosophies” that proclaim in all simplicity: “we don’t need answers and don’t need much stuff, we just need to figure out the best way to live.” Then, and only then, will we be happy.

As for Pyrrho: If you’d asked him Who rules the Universe?, he might have replied: Lord knows. Cats, again. And pigs.
pig 

Reminding us of Pyrrho’s famous pig, who impressed Montaigne by riding out a storm at sea with much greater equanimity (and, crucially, much less comprehension) than his human shipmates, and of J.S. Mill’s declaration that it’s “better to be a human dissatisfied than a pig satisfied,” Hecht comments: “This whole pig-versus-philosopher debate is pretty hilarious, yes?”

Yes. But I agree with Spinoza and Hecht. “The happiness of a drunkard is not the happiness of the wise,” though of course there are happy occasions when it has its place too. Bottom line: “Knowledge and wisdom are worth it,” it can be everything to have found true love and meaningful work, and both– all-- can end in a flash, without warning. Stay on your toes, but don’t fret too much about the storm.
piranha
One more little animal image for Pyrrho, whose name I prefer to pronounce compatibly with this mnemonic trick: just remember that a pyrrhonic skeptic is like a piranha fish, toothily devouring every proposed candidate for belief. Cats and pigs too, probably.

And as for Epicurus, Jennifer Hecht‘s got his number. It’s listed.
For an Epicurean, somewhere there are beings that are truly at peace, are happy… The mere idea of this gentle bliss is, itself, a kind of uplifting dream. After all, we human beings know a strange thing: happiness responds to circumstances, but, basically, it is internal. We can experience it when it happens to come upon us; we can induce it with practices or drugs; but we cannot just be happy.

No, we must work to “solve the schism” between how we feel and how we want to feel. Happiness is a choice and a lifetime endeavor, and though it comes easier for some than for others there are tips and tricks we can use to trip our internal happy meters and achieve ataraxia, peace of mind, simple contentment, “tranquillity, or the freedom from disturbance and pain that characterizes a balanced mind and constitutes its first step toward the achievement of pleasure.”

Stop fearing the harmless and remote gods, Epicurus said. Stop fearing your own death, it’s not (as Wittgenstein would echo, millennia later) an event you’ll ever experience. “Life is full of sweetness. We might as well enjoy it.”

*Sissela Bok calls Epicurus a hedonist, but that's only technically correct. Yes, he said pleasure's at the heart of happiness. But what kind of pleasure?

A happy life is tranquil, simple, loving, and above all free from pain, fear, and suffering, available to all regardless of social status, nationality, or gender. Such a life of pleasure, Epicurus held, would of necessity have to be a virtuous one; ...


That’s Alain de Botton, author of a text I used to use in this course, and controversial proponent of religion for atheists. (Don’t confuse him with Boethius.) His interview with Krista Tippett was instructive. Like Jennifer Hecht, he wants us to use philosophy to enhance our bliss and sweeten our dreams.

Pyrrhonian deep skepticism and moral/cultural relativism share a common root. Simon Blackburn voices the right reply to those who say we can function without beliefs, or without discriminating between better and worse beliefs, when he points out that this is simply impractical and socially dysfunctional. Not only might you get run over by a racing chariot or step off a cliff, you also scatter seeds of discord within your community and perhaps even your family.

So I too “would defend the practical importance of thinking about ethics on pragmatic grounds.” To pretend  with “Rosy the Relativist” that we can all simply have and act on our own truths, our own facts, without confronting and negotiating our differences and critically evaluating our respective statements of (dis)belief, really is “farcical.” Lord knows.

I’ve been thinking some more, btw, about a student’s question whether Oprah is a philosopher. I’d say she has philosophical moments, sometimes asks the hard questions, and is indeed seeking to have and share a “graceful” (if opulent) life. So, sure. Same for the poets (like Whitman) who let us off the hook for contradicting ourselves (“I contain multitudes.”) I don’t think the Philosophy Club should be exclusive or restrictive. Many of my colleagues would disagree, amongst themselves, at their annual association meetings and in their ivory towers. They’ll never give me a car, either.

Anyway: we won’t suffer a meaning deficit, though, if we live simply and naturally in the company of friends who’ll help us conquer our fears and address our many questions about life, the universe, and everything. That’s the Epicurean way, when we decide nature’s already provided enough for our peace of mind and our contentment. That’s ataraxia.

So finally there are these dots, connecting Epicurus and Pyrrho:
Epicurus, though no friend to skepticism, admired Pyrrho because he recommended and practiced the kind of self-control that fostered tranquillity; this, for Epicurus, was the end of all physical and moral science. Pyrrho was so highly valued by his countrymen that they honored him with the office of chief priest and, out of respect for him, passed a decree by which all philosophers were made immune from taxation.

Tranquility and a free ride: now that would make me happy. A free ride to the APA, not so much.

Thursday, February 6, 2014

Moving on

Moved office yesterday, down the hall into the marginally smaller but windowed office recently vacated by a colleague who prefers a few interior square feet to natural light and an open vista. Now I look up from my desk and screen to trees and sky, and feel as though my workspace and headspace has expanded exponentially. I'm happily transplanted.

I'm also worn out. So many trips up and down the hall, schlepping my two-wheeler's overload of bookcases, books, and the detritus of more than a decade's ratpacking. I'd pretty well covered all four walls, too, with pictures and posters and cartoons and post-its and all. Seems like one of our student workers might have thought to ask if I could use a hand.

This would not be a good time for my wife to raise again the question of moving house.

But I can't wait, now, to arrive at my desk in the morning. That's worth a few aches and pains.

When I get to my desk I'll dig in to Alastair Campbell's last chapter, on Bioethics and Justice, and to Owen Flanagan's penultimate chapter (my Honors lecture audience on Monday was apparently challenged to grasp the meaning of that word, btw) on"Neuroscience, Happiness, and Positive Illusions."

Here's a positive belief that may well prove harmlessly illusory: my new space will make me a better teacher and a happier human.

And here's a firm prediction: I won't voluntarily move office again, ever. Not without "Three Guys and a Truck." Or at least one diligent student worker.


Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Aristotle to Outlaw

We have Aristotle on two tracks (the Little History and Philosophy Bites) today in CoPhi, and on the third a "Woody Allen-ish" philosopher from New York (Canada originally), Lou Marinoff. He's featured in today's reading from America the Philosophical, as is local star Lucius Outlaw. 

We're still waiting for Woody's real apology, not that it'd ever be enough to rectify the harm for which he stands accused. Sounds like he needs to see a battery of counselors, of all kinds: philosophical, psychiatric, legal...

Aristotle‘s in the Pythons' philosopher's song too, though he's even more sober than his Ionian predecessors. He rejected his teacher Plato’s metaphysics, returned to the cave of the phenomenal world to take a closer look, avoided universalizing abstractions and CAPS (preferring forms in things to transcendent and remote FORMS "above"), and inspired the name of our annual Spring speaker series in the philosophy department at MTSU, the Lyceum. 

Our first-ever Fall Lyceum was in November. Carlin Romano came and explained why America, contrary to popular prejudice, really is a vibrantly philosophical civilization. You just have to look in the right places. His book will show us where.

The best quick & graphic way of illustrating the difference between Plato and his student Aristotle, I’ve found, is by pondering Raphael’s famous painting School of Athens [annotated]. Pay close attention to the hands.

Aristotle said one swallow doesn't make a summer, and a few moments of pleasure don't add up to a happy life. Nor does a "happy childhood." We must be in it for the long haul, and must see our good as coordinate with that of others including those who'll succeed us after we're gone. It's all about eudaimonia ("you die" is a helpful mnemonic, aggressive and hostile though it sounds, and though it really means you live.)

Aristotle was a naturalist, noticing our continuity with the rest of nature. Like trees and plants we flourish when well-nurtured. Unlike them, we must take charge of our own nurture in order to reach our potential.

It's so ironic that the middle ages made Aristotle "The Philosopher," i.e. the unquestioned Authority. That was indeed "against the spirit of philosophy."

Terence Irwin's podcast interview is compelling listening, for those unaccustomed to a Yorkshire accent (or whatever it is). He makes the same point I just did about coordinating the personal and the public good, and "identifying one's own interest with other people's interest" etc. 

He also helpfully corrects overly-simple reductions of Aristotle's ethics to a dogged middle-of-the-roadism. Avoiding extremes doesn't mean choosing the blandest, milk-toastiest possibility. It means doing the right thing at the right time for the right reason etc., and that could very well turn out to be something exciting. Or scary. (Like bombing Syria? What would Aristotle say?)

I used Lou Marinoff's Plato, Not Prozac in Intro (before it was CoPhi) some years ago. Was a bit tempted to experiment with hanging out a shingle and seeing whether the market could bear my therapeutic presence. One of these days, maybe.

Best intro to him might be this Times feature from awhile back.
...philosophical counselors disagree on everything from the best name -- philosophical practice? public philosophy? -- to whether they should be trying to cure people, empower them or guide them to self-understanding...
Marinoff and other practitioners hold that we all have a philosophy of life, whether we know it or not, and that we can benefit from identifying that philosophy, making sure it helps us rather than hinders us -- defining success, say, in a way we might actually achieve it -- and then strengthening it through dialogue with the great thinkers. 
Sounds reasonable enough, doesn't it? But when professions and income levels collide, controversy ensues.

Lucius Outlaw was a pioneering African-American philosopher who studied at Fisk. He's at Vanderbilt now (where he's said some terrific things about teaching, learning, and love). I'm not quite sure why Carlin Romano's chosen to shine such a spotlight on him. Possibly just because most of us hadn't heard of him, and he doesn't deserve such obscurity. 

The most prominent African-American philosopher in America is Cornel West, "in a league of his own" in Outlaw's own words. Here he is in London last year with our first podcast interviewee, MM McCabe (Socrates), and then in the public sphere of NYC, in a taxi, in and on "the examined life."





Kwame Anthony Appiah, London-born Ghanaian-raised, Cambridge-educated, and Princeton-based, is another African-heritage philosopher in America we should all know. HisCosmopolitanism, discussed here, would be required reading in every school, if I were philospher-king. He too was featured in The Examined Life, articulating why it's not only okay for people to be different but actually imperative. And healthy.
See also his wonderful talk on "Ethics in a World of Strangers."

There have been important African-American philosophers all along, including (notably) W.E.B. DuBois and (arguably) Booker T. Washington. And then there's Hubert Harrison.




Hubert Harrison, the “Black Socrates,” defies the stereotype of unblinking theism among African-Americans. He also admired Paine, noted errors in the Bible, and embraced Agnosticism (“such an agnostic as Huxley was”).  He said he had no intention of bowing down to a lily-white god or worshipping a Jim Crow Jesus. He was more than a little literal when he also embraced Nietzsche’s repudiation of “slave ethics.” Admitting that reason alone did not meet his every need, he still preferred “to go to the grave with my eyes open.” That’s a really good personal credo, “eyes open.” Mind too. Jennifer Michael Hecht, Doubt: A History
One more thing. The Bible book of Ecclesiastes came up in class yesterday (it seems to be in Grayling's Good Book) as we pondered a humanist's "lamentations." Seems crucial, from an Aristotelian or Marinoffian or just plain life perspective, to try and get clear on just what the author was trying to say. Surely not that you have to die and be one of the proud, the few, the "elect," to be happy. I prefer Jennifer Hecht's gloss:
Koheleth brushed aside the dream of an afterlife with a simple appeal to reason--Who knows this?--and the conclusion that humans have nothing above the beasts in this regard...
But it doesn't follow that simple happiness is unavailable in this life. The recipe's pretty simple.
Love your spouse. Get some work to do, do it with all your might; enjoy the simple pleasures of food, drink, and love. Everything else is vanity. 
But, it's a form of vanity we can live with. The search for true love, solid friendship, good work, and daily delight might just be enough. Enjoy your life. A person could do worse. The search for happiness on this orb is anything but a "dismal" undertaking, as someone sadly suggested. You could ask Aristotle. It's the end and aim of life.

Tuesday, February 4, 2014

Research, and the good life for all

Did the Honors lecture yesterday. That was fun! Can't believe it's been nearly five years since the last time.

Today in Bioethics we'll talk "research." Things like clinical trials and research involving animals and their rights, and genetics, and epidemiology. We'll look at the funding gap between what we need to cure and where our research dollars are actually going, and at the moral imperative of genuine and informed consent. We'll look at disturbing instances of fraudulent and dishonest research. And we'll consider Peter Singer's claims about "speciesism."



The future of research is a daunting source of apprehension and speculation. Michael Sandel and Bill McKibben have aired serious concerns about genetic and other "enhancement" research as potentially catastrophic for our capacity to achieve or even recognize "meaningful" lives. Enhanced may not mean improved.

The Times has a cover story today we should notice: Ethicists are split over the use of genetic testing of embryos... to ensure [parents] that a bad gene would not be passed to their children.
In A&P, it's neuroscience and the good life with Owen Flanagan, as we continue to plow through The Really Hard Problem. (He made it into my honors lecture yesterday, btw, as a cherry-picking Blue Devil "modern-day pragmatist." Maybe we can take a peek at a couple of my slides today.

Many philosophers continue to look askance at Flanagan's empirical and hypothetical approach to eudaimonistic scientia, and to the suggestion that some facts about flourishing should inform our "value judgments." I'm still trying to understand why. Is it misplaced loyalty to a miscast reverence for Saint David of Edinburgh? Or for Aristotle? Or Buddha?

And speaking of the happiest, flow-iest man on earth, Mathieu Ricard...

We look as well today at Flanagan's discussion of Stoics, Skeptics, and Epicureans. "The good life for all," he says, is a more demanding ethic than Aristotle's. Nobody ever said democracy would be easy.

Buddhist psychology is all about alleviating suffering. I wonder if it's enough about optimizing joy, too. And this will inevitably bring us back to one of next time's topics, illusion. Might be worth revisiting a HAP 101 session, early last Fall, devoted to the theme.

Flanagan's main refrain, still, is that we give up our childish habits of thought and live up to our birthright as rational social animals who can handle the truth about our condition as finite material beings living in a material world. Can't argue with that, but I hope we'll draw a careful distinction between childish and child-like. That might be just the distinction a cherry-picking pragmatic pluralist needs, to preserve the integrity of the "thousand-eyed present."

Monday, February 3, 2014

Caving to reality

Did the groundhog's shadow recur yesterday?  Not around these parts, we awake to freezing drizzle. But six weeks more of winter or not, with football fading I'm counting the days (just 10!) 'til pitchers and catchers report. February brings Spring.

We commence engaging all three of our texts in CoPhi today, the full panoply, with the Little History discussion of Socrates and Plato and Philosophy Bites podcast interviews with MM McCabe on the Socratic method and Angie Hobbs on Platonic eros. Plus, the rest of the introduction to Carlin Romano's America the Philosophical. A full menu, it'll be filling. And good. 

Remember, sec.12 of Peck Hall: we're not meeting at 2:20 today, but you're invited to my Honors lecture on Health & Happiness at 3 pm in the Paul Martin Building, Room 106. I'll be presenting, as usual, a pragmatic perspective.
In the southern part of Europe is a little country called Greece… the Greeks have lived in it for more than three thousand years. In olden times they believed that before they came to the land it was the home of the gods, and they used to tell wonderful stories…


And then Socrates came along to challenge some of those stories. (There actually were some important pre-Socratics like Thales and Democritus already challenging what everybody knew, but we’re jumping ahead in our Little History.) And that’s why, from a western philosopher’s point of view, the Greeks matter.

The old Parthenon must have been lovely, but I think ours is prettier nowadays.
??????????

Socrates, from Alopece, near Athens, asked a lot of questions. Like Bertrand Russell:


In all affairs it's a healthy thing now and then to hang a question mark on the things you have long taken for granted.

Did curiosity kill the philosopher? No, a narrow plurality of 500 jurors did. (His unrepentant attitude during sentencing didn't help, either.) They convicted him of "impiety" (atheism) and corrupting the youth of Athens. One more reason I'm lucky to live in the 21st century: I don't like hemlock. I'm like Woody Allen, that way. (But if shocking new allegations are true, hemlock may be too good for him.)

He was “snub-nosed, podgy, shabby and a bit strange,” says our text. "He was ugly," says podcastee Mary McCabe. But brilliant and charismatic too, as gadflies go.  Said he had nothing to teach, but those around him (including young Plato) said they learned plenty from him, especially how 
to discuss with others in this open-minded, open-ended way that allows them to reflect on what they think and us to reflect on what we think, without dictating, without dogma, without insistence, and without imperative... to be true to themselves: to be sincere about their beliefs and to be honest... and to have some respect for their companion.
 If that's not good teaching, what is? 




"Plato, they say, could stick it away..." -they being Monty Python. And the late great Hitch sang it too, sorta. But Plato was a serious and sober fellow, in Reality, usually capitalizing that word to distinguish it from mere appearance. The everyday world is not at all what it appears to be, he said. If you want Truth and Reality and the Good, get out of your cave and go behold the Forms. He seemed to think that’s what his hero Socrates had done. I’m not so sure. But read the relevant Platonic dialogues telling the tragic and inspiring story of the last days of Socrates and see what you think.

He also had interesting thoughts about love and eros, as expressed through his constant dialogue character "Socrates" (who may or may not have spoken faithfully for his martyred namesake) in Symposium. Angie Hobbs says Plato rejected Aristophanes' mythic notion that we all have one unique other "half," formerly parts of our hermaphroditic spherical selves, that would complete us and make us happy. But he defended a view some of us find equally implausible, the idea that the true and highest love spurns particular persons and embraces the Form of Beauty.

The Form of Beauty "is always going to be there for you," but on the other hand "it's never going to love you back." Unrequited affection is hardly what most of us think of as Perfect Love. There's a myth for you. "Pain, fragility, and transience" don't sound like much, but try sustaining a relationship without them. That's the story and the glory of human love, no? Just ask Cecil the Butler about Sidney Poitier.

Thursday, January 30, 2014

Clinical ethics, Buddhism, Consolations

Was up way before dawn today, but instead of repairing promptly to the blogspot I had instead to deal with dogs. They usually live in their own space out back, in the "barn," but with the mercury dipping so low we brought 'em in. So, lucky me, I got to take 'em out at 5 am and experience the thrill of polar vortex at first hand.

It didn't kill me. In fact it inspired. What a magnificent planetarium show I've been missing. The stars! So amazing always, but even more boggling when you've just stumbled out of slumber and not quite come back to yourself. Why do we let ourselves sleep and blog obliviously through that, day after day, when we could be gazing and wondering at eternity? Another cost of comfort we forget to calculate.

But it did throw me off my routine. I'm sold on the life- and meaning-giving properties of habit, but a little deviation from time to time is good for the spirit. There's a cosmic meaning-space out there you can't really find any other time of day. Mustn't be a stranger to it.

Today in Bioethics: clinical ethics issues like the status of fetal life, transplantation, regenerative medicine, mental health, end of life care, and much more. The binding thread is respect for the lives, autonomy and dignity of all humans, including (from the POV of caregivers) all patients. 

And that connects nicely with today's A&P topic, Buddhism & Science. Owen Flanagan is interested in naturalizing Buddhism, making it safe and meaningful for atheists and humanists. There too, the thread that binds is one of respect for all sentient beings, compassion for their suffering, amelioration of their pain.

Pain and suffering give rise to Lamentations, which in turn elicit Consolations in our humanist Good Book. We'll again go around our circle of friends and nominate favorite verses. I like those of the Stoics. Two jump out at me this morning, with the memory of loss fresh in mind. (Seneca is the source here, I think.)
"The remembrance of lost friends is a good; It honors them and consoles us, and keeps them with us in our hearts." Consolations 4.16-17
"Whatever can happen at any time can happen today." Consolations 4.39
And then, again, there is the deep cosmic consolation of the stars. We are starstuff, we are golden, we are in the garden already. We must tend it.


Wednesday, January 29, 2014

Philosophy in America?


In CoPhi today we'll start getting acquainted with America the Philosophical. Carlin Romano (who came to MTSU last November to inaugurate our new Fall Lyceum) says everybody who thinks America is un- or a- or even anti-philosophical has just not dug deep and wide enough. Especially wide. As the poet said, we are vast and contain contradictory multitudes. We're philosophical at the roots, where we're not weedy.  But of course, he concedes, we're also vain and superficial and unconscious all across the landscape too. We're in the weeds with Jersey Shore and American Idol and Honey Boo-Boo and Dennis Rodman, but maybe not with Camille Paglia and Oprah. It's easy, too easy, to overlook all the philosophizing that's all around us. Carlin Romano's critics (and Camille's and Oprah's) will say he's found it all too easy to see. 




Carlin's thesis will strike many, especially your entrenched working class of paid professional philosophers, as itself radical. He's breaking their rules. defying what Richard Rorty called their "scholastic little definitions of philosophy."  But as James says in the opening epigraph, "between us and the universe, there are no 'rules of the game.'" America, Romano insists and tries to document in his book, "America in the early twenty-first century towers as the most philosophical culture in the history of the world." Wow. Can he back that up? We'll see.

One point of immediate concern is the claim that in America there exists a "widespread rejection of truths imposed by authority or tradition alone." Hmmm. That's not exactly been my experience, confronting prejudice in the classroom. Wish I had a nickel for every time I've heard "that's just the way I was raised" or some variant thereof, in declining the invitation to think or even listen. And I don't just get this from Braves and Sox fans.

As I said  the other day, "brave thinking about truth is the secret to happiness." Or can be, for some of us. It's the secret to intellectual honesty and philosophical integrity for us all.
If you believe X because dad or preacher or bible or teacher or tradition or a little voice told you so, that's unphilosophical. If you believe it because you experienced something that you think supports it, and are prepared to discuss that experience and that belief, then we can reason amicably together. 
Carlin's AtP introduction goes on to mention the source of one big embarrassment in the profession of philosophy in America, Professor Colin McGinn (formerly of the U. of Miami, also mentioned in the recent NYTimes philosophy blog The Stone as signifying a positive watershed moment for women in the field), and several of my own influences: John Rawls ("widely touted as the greatest American political philosopher"), Alain de Botton (a popularizer and twitter star), several popular philosophy mags, Harry Frankfurt (On Bullshit), philosophical novelists Iris Murdoch and Rebecca (36 Arguments for the Existence of God) Goldstein, Sophie's World (a great read for Intro students, my colleague Bombardi says), Monty Python ("Socrates himself was permanently pissed..."), Matthew Lipman, Hannah Arendt, Mooney & Kirshenbaum (Unscientific America), Susan Jacoby (Age of American Unreason), NPR and BookTV (the new middlebrow standard-bearers), Chris Phillips (Socrates Cafe, Socrates in Love), Open Court and Blackwell publishers (The Simpsons, The Matrix, Facebook...& Philosophy... and don't forget Jimmy Buffett), X-phi, cyber-phi, Richard Rorty, Oliver Sacks, Robert Fulghum, Cornel West, Obama-the-pragmatist, Isocrates... (Wait: Isocrates? Where'd the "I" come from?)

Notice how many of those names and works have emerged not from academia but from the wider world. That's Romano's point: philosophy in America's way bigger than we (and the APA) thought. I'm not sure I'd include The Playboy Philosophy in that list, as Carlin does, but we'll see.

One more question, students: Is Carlin right when he writes that you "couldn't name a contemporary academic philosopher" to save your life? If so, please allow me to re-introduce myself, then. I am not a man of wealth and fame, but I am an heir to Socrates. My job is to "corrupt" you and your fellow "youth." My job is to encourage you to think.

That's not always an easy job, but it's doable. Bertrand Russell said some young people have the habit of thinking, while "one of the aims of education is to cure them of this habit." That's not my aim. 

Russell also said most people would rather die than think, and most do.

Don't let it happen to you. Sapere aude, kids. If AtP is right, you're in the right place to do it.