Delight Springs

Monday, September 30, 2024

Play's the thing

Finished Playground, but I don’t think it’s finished with me. The themes of play, story, evolution, death and life, and this wondrous but under-appreciated oceanic planet where they all play out will resonate. We’d like it to be an infinite game, continuing for the sake of the play itself. But we may be in the process of writing our final chapters. 

Powers's final chapter, in this book, gets the game:
But the look the humans share says: What does it look like? Call it what it is. Every dance is a game, and every game its own best explanation. Everything alive, even we newcomers. . . . What are all creatures—even me—doing at all times but playing in the world, playing before their tinkering Lord?

Our tinkering Lord is natural selection, with or without a pre-meditative tinkerer. Play on, Hamlet. And Richard. Can't wait for the sequel. 

(And because the mlb regular season ends today, let's play into the post-season. Then, start counting the days to Spring Training.)


Saturday, September 28, 2024

part of the stream

"To be happy in this world, especially when youth is past, it is necessary to feel oneself not merely an isolated individual whose day will soon be over, but part of the stream of life flowing on from the first germ to the remote and unknown future."

— Bertrand Russell, The Conquest of Happiness

Friday, September 27, 2024

Anxiety: the bright side

MTSU's Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies is hosting its first Applied Philosophy Lyceum of the academic year on Friday, September 27, 2024, at 5:00 PM in COE 164. Catered reception following.

Looking forward to introducing our Lyceum speaker this afternoon, assuming we're not flooded out…



I'm delighted today to introduce Dr. Mariana Alessandri, professor of philosophy at University of Texas-Rio Grande Valley and (it is possibly relevant to note) a New Yorker.


I met Dr. Alessandri last Spring in Boston at the Society for the Advancement of American Philosophy's annual meeting, and immediately thought she'd make an excellent Lyceum guest. The author-meets-critics session devoted to her 2023 book Night Vision: Seeing Ourselves Through Dark Moods, was enlightening, insightful, entertaining, and even at points actually cheerful.

I do understand that when she writes "Against Cheerfulness," she means forced and phony cheer, the "American way [that] borders on psychosis." I don't think she's against the spontaneous and natural sort of joi'e de vivre that even the gloomiest of Guses can occasionally enjoy. No less committed a Scrooge than Schopenhauer, after all, said

"Cheerfulness is a direct and immediate gain, — the very coin, as it were, of happiness… for it alone makes us immediately happy in the present moment, and that is the highest blessing for beings like us, whose existence is but an infinitesimal moment between two eternities. To secure and promote this feeling of cheerfulness should be the supreme aim of all our endeavors after happiness." -The Wisdom of Life



Schopenhauer--the guy who said “What disturbs and depresses young people is the hunt for happiness on the firm assumption that it must be met with in life"-- said that

But he also said "It is difficult to find happiness within oneself, but it is impossible to find it anywhere else."

And aren't we in fact, in this present moment, happy to be here and looking forward to learning about feeling better about all kinds of feelings?


Dr. Alessandri has written widely and in public, contributing (according to its editor) some of the New York Times philosophy series The Stone's most impressive essays. One of those, in 2019, found the late Fred Rogers' dark side: "It's A Terrible Day in the Neighborhood and That's Okay" concludes:

"If we are convinced by Rogers' and Aristotle's claim that feelings are not wrong and that "what's mentionable is manageable," we should begin mentioning our own sad, lonely and disappointed feelings. In doing so, we would show children — and our grown-up selves — how to appropriately manage them."

Dr. Alessandri introduces herself, on her website, this way:

"I'm a teacher, philosopher, accidental activist, and mother, but if I could be a superhero, my cape would read: 'Defender of Dark Moods.'

As long as I live in a world where people apologize for crying in public, I will write books and essays on why complaining is good, why [fake] cheerfulness isn't, and why Mister Rogers was right that "everyone has lots of ways of feeling and all of those feelings are fine." You can find [her] my work at The New York Times, New Philosopher, Womankind, [Aeon,] and other places."

[And] Check out what drives [her] nuts on Instagram and in her newsletter, In the Cave.

Speaking myself as a mostly-happy melioristic pragmatic pluralist, and despite her reluctance during the Q-&-A in Boston to endorse the hopeful positivity of meliorism, I was gratified by Dr. Alessandri's inscription in my copy of her book: "Dear Phil, I think the pragmatists and existentialists have a lot of common ground!"

And so we have.


Please join me in welcoming


DR. MARIANA ALESSANDRI

Professor, University of Texas Rio Grande Valley

 

“THE UPSIDE OF ANXIETY: Kierkegaard on feeling better about feeling bad”

 

Is anxiety best described as a lack of faith, an error in reasoning, or a brain disease/chemical imbalance? Do any of our contemporary definitions or descriptions of anxiety help us feel better about it? In 1844, the “congenitally anxious” philosopher Søren Kierkegaard posited that the more anxious a civilization is, the more profound the culture. Can Kierkegaard’s defense of anxiety help us, in 2024, to feel better about feeling bad?

 

Join Dr. Mariana Alessandri, Professor in the Department of Philosophy at the University of Texas Rio Grande Valley, and author of Night Vision: Seeing Ourselves Through Dark Moods, as she talks about the mental illness that 1 in 3 college students suffers from.

 

 

* This event is free and open to the public. A reception will follow the discussion.


Tuesday, September 24, 2024

Playground

I woke up way early this morning to start reading the story that's been described as doing for oceans what "Overstory" did for trees...


http://dlvr.it/TDdSS9

Playground

Richard Powers' new novel was waiting for me in my kindle library this morning. A Kant-Rousseau moment: everything else must wait, while I read.


And here's a passage that describes my every trip to Parnassus:

"I WANDERED AROUND THE BOOKSTORE for so long looking for my prize that my father lost it. "All right, already. Pick one and be done with it." But that was the problem: How could I pick the right one when it might be any book in the entire store? Thousands of them. Tens of thousands. I started my rounds again, across Chicago's finest chain bookstore's two large floors. "Five minutes," my father said. "Then I'm picking one for you." I was in the Nature and Science section of the Young Adult books when my eyes fell on a turquoise spine with shimmering letters that read Clearly It Is Ocean. I opened the book and was dismayed. The font was smaller and denser than I liked. But the pictures of surreal sea life were incredible, and I wanted them. On the back was a picture of a skinny woman with long red hair and a diving mask pulled up over her radiant face. I had never seen an adult look so fulfilled. One glance at the author and I fell in love as only a ten-year-old can. My father scowled at my choice. "Are you sure?" I was sure. "Are you sure you're sure?" He waved his hand, taking in all the superior treasures that I was passing up. I was sure. The author in the photo was sure. All the fish in all the lakes and oceans were sure. Clearly this was the book I was meant to have."

— Playground: A Novel by Richard Powers
https://a.co/5o7xdRt

Saturday, September 14, 2024

Richard Powers on What We Do to the Earth and What It Does to Us

Eagerly anticipating "Playground"…

Should we be feeling awe, delight, terror about the environment, AI, etc.?

"Do I have to choose one of them? I mean, all of them. Don't you feel all of them?" 

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2024/09/16/richard-powers-profile

Wednesday, September 11, 2024

9/11

23 years, before most of my students were born.

Macho “Stoics” on the internet

I was asked in class yesterday about how some internet popularizers of Stoicism seem to equate that philosophy with "masculine values"… This seems relevant:

"Working through a book with some students yesterday and had a realization.💡

Many of us would agree that our culture is broadly nihilistic — lot of despair, feelings of pointlessness, atomization, and isolation. "Does anything matter?!"

A lot of the toxic stuff online targeting young men is flourishing IN THIS CONTEXT. Guys are offered "systems," and "discipline," and "tradition" as a balm for this aimlessness and anxiety about meaning."

👇 https://www.threads.net/@greatbooksprof/post/C_vF9PnusBk/?xmt=AQGziKuazBiKpApNr6Oa7gCvvqV9D39ZVA3FnnNdKNkC_Q

Tuesday, September 10, 2024

Monday, September 9, 2024

How the Philosopher Charles Taylor Would Heal the Ills of Modernity

"Poetry and music escape the constraints of intellect, Taylor argues, persuading us by inspiration rather than argument." 

Does his argument inspire?

Does reason alone reveal the constraints of intellect? 

Or does experience, a broader category of wisdom? 

Asking for the friend who shared the essay and said: "It's the music that's alleged to do the work. But Taylor's work comprises arguments, not music or poetry. Does reason provide evidence of its own limitations? I find that sort of view attractive."

In other words: define "reason"…

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2024/06/24/cosmic-connections-charles-taylor-book-review

Friday, September 6, 2024

“Divisive concepts” form (for the convenience of my students)

Why fascists hate universities | Jason Stanley | The Guardian

"…Even more so than Florida, Tennessee is a one-party state, with a Republican governor and a Republican supermajority in the legislature. The Tennessee house and senate passed a resolutionto honor the Danube Institute; on the floor of the Tennessee house, the state representative Justin Jones questioned why the state was honoring the Hungarian autocrat Viktor Orbán's thinktank. Tennessee has a state ban on the teaching of "divisive concepts", one that includes public universities. To report a professor for teaching such a concept (such as intersectionality), Tennessee provides an online form..."

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/article/2024/sep/05/why-fascists-hate-universities-us-bangladesh-india