Delight Springs

Tuesday, June 8, 2021

Growing up enlightened, and walking on

LISTEN. Going for the pre-op consultation this morning, this surgery adventure is about to get real. If I must be carnally invaded (and I must, dogwalks have become excruciating), minimally is the adverb of choice. It seems the enlightened thing to do, under the circumstances. 

This evening in Enlightenment we'll open Susan Neiman's Why Grow Up? Subversive Thoughts for an Infantile Age. Being enlightened, for her as for her hero Kant, means accepting the way things are while still striving to do what can be done to make them better. It's very close to what I (following William James) call *meliorism, and what my mentor Lachs calls Stoic Pragmatism. 

"Age clarifies," begins Lachs's eponymous book. Garrison Keillor said a similar thing in a recent essay. "I expected to be grumpy in old age and of course there’s still time, but instead I’m awestruck..." (But then he also said some appropriately grumpy things about the state of academia, and the way it can leach the life and interest out of its subject-matter...)

Lachs: "Stoic pragmatists are committed to making life better until their powers are overwhelmed... pragmatists are unlikely ever to give up, while stoics may give up too soon." (Is that why the classicist Mary Beard intemperately describes Stoicism as "nasty, fatalistic, bordering on fascist..."?) 

Enlightened stoic pragmatists explore their options.  

Susan Neiman strikes me as such an explorer. She says you're fooling yourself if you think youth is the happiest time of life. Ask Grandfather Philosophy. Enlightened maturity is best, though her hero Kant was more about deserving than actually achieving happiness. We should go for both. You should not have to "renounce your hopes and dreams" to get what you want and need. That's Stones (not Stone) philosophy.

In "What is Enlightenment?" (1784) Kant answered his own question promptly and succinctly, for once. "Enlightenment is man's emergence from his self-incurred immaturity. Immaturity is the inability to use one's own understanding without the guidance of another. This immaturity is self-incurred if its cause is not lack of understanding, but lack of resolution and courage to use it without the guidance of another. The motto of enlightenment is therefore: Sapere aude! Have courage to use your own understanding!"

In a distracted age like ours, and a country like ours (like Brian's) where we're so lockstep-sure that we're all individuals, it takes a resolute and committed will to think for yourself. Even those who think they're thinking may just be re-arranging their prejudices, William James probably wasn't the first to say. Most people would die sooner than think, Bertrand Russell repeated. Real originality is hard. Don't believe everything you read on the Internet, Honest Abe.

But I can vouch for the accuracy of this statement from Susan Neiman: "All the information in the world is no substitute for the guts to use your own judgement... Judgement is important because none of the answers to the questions that really move us can be found by following a rule." Surprising statement from a Kantian, though even he was probably not much moved by the Categorical Imperative. Point is, there's a big gap between the way things are (according to experience) and the way reason tells us they could and should be. "Growing up requires confronting the gap between the two, without giving up on either one."

If travel is essential for growing up, the pandemic's really set us back. Former Harvard President and Obama Treasury Secretary Larry Summers's disdain for language-learning would too. As we've noted in CoPhi, discussing Julian Baggini's How the World Thinks (and as Wittgenstein's "language games" imply), learning a language is inseparable from thinking new thoughts and expanding your mental world.

Is 18 to 28 the best time of life? Neiman thinks it's the hardest, made harder by the conceit that you should be loving it then and missing it the rest of your life. Better to look forward with the poet to a long and gratifying maturation. "Grow old along with me, the best is yet to be, the last of life, for which the first was made."

Well, I'm hoping "the best" doesn't include the worst debilitating effects of neuropathy and spinal stenosis. I'm looking forward, in the last of life --way before the last, actually-- to getting my groove back. And my reliably durable stride. 
==
* "...there are unhappy men who think the salvation of the world impossible. Theirs is the doctrine known as pessimism.

Optimism in turn would be the doctrine that thinks the world's salvation inevitable.

Midway between the two there stands what may be called the doctrine of meliorism, tho it has hitherto figured less as a doctrine than as an attitude in human affairs. Optimism has always been the regnant DOCTRINE in european philosophy. Pessimism was only recently introduced by Schopenhauer and counts few systematic defenders as yet. Meliorism treats salvation as neither inevitable nor impossible. It treats it as a possibility, which becomes more and more of a probability the more numerous the actual conditions of salvation become..." Pragmatism: A New Name for Some Old Ways of Thinking

Monday, June 7, 2021

Pascal + Murrow in bricks

An exaggeration, surely. But I'll wager he was onto something.


Thanks to social media we can sit alone in a room and be heard around the world. Is that progress?

Friday, June 4, 2021

Integrity

 Younger Daughter wanted to gamble, to celebrate her 22d birthday and her recent college graduation. So she and Mom traipsed off to southern Indiana, while I stayed home with the dogs and cat and taught my Enlightenment class. 

And, I found yet another compelling Cornel West sermon on YouTube. This one happened to be at Southern Indiana University, not far from the gambling den in Evansville.


I've been on a West kick lately. I've always appreciated his energy and intelligence and humanity. And passion for justice. In this address the keyword seems to be integrity. He's always name-dropping Dostoevsky, I must find a way to get him into my Brothers K talk at Ottawa.

Younger Daughter broke even, btw, and reports having seen many desperate addicts of many kinds. Maybe that trip cured her of the allure of winning big all at once. Our biggest wins take time and commitment, and dedication. Perseverence. Love. Integrity, in Dr. W's impassioned drawl. He says his daughter told him she appreciates his dedication to lost causes. But there's never a right time to fold, when justice is at stake.

Got some nice souvenirs out of my family's adventure. Love the socks' summons to integrity.

 

"...we must remember that the basis of democratic leadership is ordinary citizens’ desire to take their country back from the hands of corrupted plutocratic and imperial elites. This desire is predicated on an awakening among the populace from the seductive lies and comforting illusions that sedate them and a moral channeling of new political energy that constitutes a formidable threat to the status quo. This is what happened in the 1860s, 1890s, 1930s, and 1960s in American history. Just as it looked as if we were about to lose the American democratic experiment—in the face of civil war, imperial greed, economic depression, and racial upheaval—in each of these periods a democratic awakening and activistic energy emerged to keep our democratic project afloat. We must work and hope for such an awakening once again." Democracy Matters: Winning the Fight Against Imperialism


Thursday, June 3, 2021

Distraction

I spent too much time yesterday fiddling with the storage on my phone, trying to figure out how to "manage" my photos and other files. 

So, I can entirely relate to what Susan Neiman says about the time we spend dealing with distraction, and with upgrading the technological marvels that are supposed to better our lives, and such. Is this really progress? Would a truly smart and enlightened age not have long since pitched its smartphones into the pond?
If one added all the hours spent by all of us on what are cheerfully called upgrades – figuring out how to navigate the new software on the computer, set the new alarm clock, grill with the new oven, store messages on the new smartphone, save pictures on the new camera, unlock the new auto ignition – wouldn’t it be enough hours to, say, produce enough food to feed the world’s hungry children, or perhaps find a cure for cancer? --Why Grow Up?: Subversive Thoughts for an Infantile Age

But that's Luddism. Our challenge is to learn to live well with our upgrades. Don't pitch it, just put it down. 

Wednesday, June 2, 2021

Brothers

 According to the internet, it's not wise to get inked shortly before surgery. Okay then. Henry's morning star remains, for now, a guiding light in my imagination but not yet on my forearm. No point in gambling gratuitously with my health, still and always worth "all the 'truths' under the firmament." Not yet.

Same goes for easing back into regular and casual public intercourse with unmasked others. Wife and Younger Daughter are at a casino in Indiana, celebrating her birthday. I was happy to stay behind and teach my class last night. Not yet, thanks. 

But I do intend to "live my life," as my wife put it, and not be unduly cowed by the specter of contagion. A life of zest is also a life of measured risk. Mustn't be blind to that.

Wherever a process of life communicates an eagerness to him who lives it, there the life becomes genuinely significant...there is the zest, the tingle, the excitement of reality; and there is 'importance' in the only real and positive sense in which importance ever anywhere can be. On a Certain Blindness in Human Beings

I'm just not interested in taking reckless risks that offer insufficient reward in compensation. 

I'm not ready to rub shoulders at the multiplex (for instance) with potentially-viral strangers here in Tennessee--one of those rebellious and least-immune southern states where so many are so belligerently unwilling to acknowledge our shared obligation to balance the personal and the public. They are benighted, not enlightened. I'll just chill here on the couch with the dogs, for now. ("Namaste home,"  as announced by the mug my wife thought it clever to gift me.)

Thinking about all this is a welcome distraction from the ticking clock, counting quickly down to the surgeons' (there are two) scalpels in less than two weeks now. I'm trying not to think too much about the "procedure," projecting ahead instead to that time in mid-July when (if all goes well) I'll be good to go up to Ottawa for that long-postponed conference. 

My topic: The Brothers Karamazov and The Brothers K ("David James Duncan's wildly excessive, flamboyantly sentimental, tear-jerking, thigh-slapping homage to Dostoyevsky and Tolstoy -- and the game of baseball"), and what both have to say about undue suffering and the absence of justice in our world.

I wonder if Brother West is a baseball fan. I know he has things to say on this topic. On every topic. Did you hear him with Brother Robert yesterday? If Thrasymachus had his way, there'd be no justice for sure. We don't need an "argument" to refute the nihilist. We don't need to refute the nihilist. We just need an eagerness to live our lives in the zest and tingle and excitement of reality. 

Sometimes we don't need to argue.

Tuesday, June 1, 2021

Lifelong teaching

Exciting news today for our Enlightenment Now class: on July 13 my old friend (and Best Man 28 years ago this past Sunday) Professor Daryl Hale--just retired from a teaching career at Western Carolina University--has agreed to zoom with the class in my absence, pinch-hitting while I'm at my Baseball in Literature and Culture conference in Ottawa KS. 

He's a Kant scholar and has regularly taught a course on Enlightenment at WCU. He's the smartest and funniest Kantian I know.  And he's also a baseball fan, and an early bird, like me. His guest stint came about just a few moments ago, when I received a text from him commenting on the Mets' amazing Jacob deGrom. Then he mentioned his retirement, after "I finished my last class on Enlightenment this spring, one of my favorites." Well, why hadn't it already occurred to me to ask him to fill in? "How stupid of one, not to have thought of that..." (As Huxley said of Darwin's natural selection.)

So I issued the invite, with the caveat that I'd understand if he was truly done with teaching. "Never done with teaching, just with grading." I get that. Like my colleague who's also retiring this summer, and like my mentor John Lachs, we can contemplate and even relish retiring from academia --(Lachs once said the great thing about tenure is that you can show the Dean any finger you like)-- but never from teaching and learning and philosophizing. 

But I'm still here tonight, when we'll finish Robertson's Very Short Intro. The two topics he raises in the second half of the book that most capture my imagination are (1) the rise of public spaces like coffeehouses, in the 17th and 18th centuries, as sociable venues for the enactment of enlightenment values (truth-seeking, mutual indulgence/toleration  etc.) and the exchange of ideas... and the decline of that sort of coffeehouse culture in our time; and (2) the rise and fall of the type of Public Intellectual in our day. 

Matthew Green also deplores the absence of conviviality among strangers in Starbucks and other commercial-chain coffee emporia nowadays. "Would you go up to a stranger in a coffee shop and ask them for the latest news?" No, they'd either be mortified or they'd likely spew a fount of fake news. I'm with him, we need a coffee revolution.

I agree with Erica Stone, "our universities have a duty to engage with the public." And our philosophers have a duty to step out of the ivory tower, if not into literal coffeehouses like Chris Phillips ("Socrates Cafe") and into pop culture celebrity like Cornel West --the two of them together are quite a duo, West by himself is by turns exhausting and exhilarating and almost always constructively provocative-- then at least into the sphere of social media where they can reach and enrich a broader public. I'm pleased to hear West in conversation with Rob Talissse on the Why We Argue podcast. Brothers!

"There is something devastatingly hollow about the demonstration that thought without action is hollow, when we find the philosopher only thinking it," as my old lifelong teacher has said. And demonstrated. Thought without action is even more hollow than concepts without percepts.

A few other questions, and my preliminary responses to what we've said about them so far:
Was Descartes right that "the mind has no sex"? 91 Do most of our contemporaries agree?

"No one knows exactly what causes gender dysphoria. Some experts believe that hormones in the womb, genes, and cultural and environmental factors may be involved..." https://medlineplus.gov/ency/article/001527.htm

It's the "cultural and environmental factors" I find most intriguing, and perhaps that's what many of us also find most confusing about this phenomenon. Or perplexing, for those who prefer a black-and-white, male-or-female world. Those of us over a certain age may be especially challenged by this brave new world of gender complexity, but the enlightened view generally is to welcome complexity and celebrate it.

I agree, whatever gender differences may impact how we view the world, they must not be allowed to occlude our common humanity in the search for truth.

1. Do you believe that language is an innate or a divine gift? (68)
2. How can the Free Masons be an essential part of the public sphere if they impose secrecy? (89)

1. Since I don't personally believe in divines, I can't see it as a divine gift. And I can't see it as a gift in the literal sense, since the only candidate for such largesse must be a god. But in the looser sense in which anything we consider a boon and an asset is a gift, I do think language is a gift... even though I also share the Jamesian ambivalence I've mentioned, noting the limits of language and the ways in which we distort life by trying to render ineffable experience in words.

The question as to whether language is innate seems to me a related but somewhat different issue. Were we humans and our antecedents always born with a capacity for language, or at least an innate "grammar" or scaffolding for symbolic communication? Or if not always, then emergently? I guess that's the Noam Chomsky line in linguistics. My line is that I can well imagine the evolutionary path of our forebears NOT having turned to language... in which case I suspect we wouldn't be here. So again, my gratitude for the "gift"... I don't think much thinking or co-philosophizing would go on without it!

2. Interesting paradox. I think of my old dad, who was a freemason (of course he never really divulged any "secrets") in much the same way, it seemed to me, as he was a member of the school board and Rotary and Kiwanis (civic organizations designed to bring merchants and small business-people and professionals together for "sociability" and boosterism etc.). In other words, freemasonry for him seemed just one more club that brought him into regular contact with his peers. I sort of see that as a way of building the public sphere.

Ben Franklin said the masons' great secret was that they had no real secrets. Ritual and clubbiness, yes. But nothing for the rest of us to be suspicious of.

Is there something there to grasp or is enlightenment unobtainable?
Would it be wrong to fit enlightenment into a paradigm of understanding that has passed into history?
Should we continue to think of enlightenment as a society in search for moral virtue?
Could communism in its truest sense be the once or a future embodiment of enlightenment?
When we think of enlightenment do we have to think of a structure that includes politics or should it just be one's own understanding of the world?
I felt that the conclusion of this book left me to wonder where the influencers of the enlightenment end?
If by enlightenment we mean a commitment to human betterment, progress, social justice, and in general the amelioration of the human condition, then that's not "there" in any sense that implies necessary existence. These are contingent states of affairs the attainment of which depends upon human agency and resolve. I can think of no reason to declare them unattainable, a priori. The point of pursuing enlightenment, like the pursuit of happiness (which on recent interpretations may simply be different aspects of the same pursuit), is to fulfill one of the crucial conditions of their attainment: our will to attain them.

Yes, I think it would be wrong to consign enlightenment to the dustbin of history... or of mere historical scholarship. Our course (following Pinker) is called Enlightenment Now. History is still being made and written.

I prefer to think of enlightenment as individuals building a better society collaboratively, in search of every kind of virtue. Moral virtue is a subset of virtue in the wide old Greek sense of arete, meaning excellence across the board and in every facet of life involving human volition.

If true communism reconciles the public interest with private freedom, and if it is realistic, then perhaps something like it is the future of enlightenment. But it'll be very different from any nominal form of communism we've yet seen.

I think we should think of enlightenment as embracing both personal and public dimensions. No need to exclude either.

I hope the "influencers" don't end at all, since we're still quite far from achieving an enlightened society. 
1: Does the Enlightenment “matter” today? 2: Had the French Revolution not occurred, would the Enlightenment (as it is defined in this book) have continued past the 18th century?
It does indeed feel like we're regressing, de-lightening, devolving, marching backwards with the rise of uncritically-minded superstition, baseless and outlandish conspiracy-mongering, blatant dishonesty etc. And that's why I think the values of enlightenment, theirs and subsequently, matter now more than ever. Progress constructed on the dispassionate (but not unimpassioned) quest for truth, facts, and reality can be our salvation. Its continued neglect will likely be our reversion to a more primitive and less hopeful condition. And yes, if we're really thinking (really THINKING) for ourselves then each of us can fashion our own sense of what enlightenment means. Our text indicates that on one interpretation that's exactly what Kant was advising, not the more absolute and objective conception of enlightenment as a categorical construction of the universal mind. We should ask Prof. Hale about that.

I wonder if a less bloody French Revolution might have contributed to a more enduring and widely-embraced form of enlightenment. If France and other European powers had remained in the grip of autocracy and coercive monarchy, on the other hand, would that have hastened an eventual revolutionary explosion of democracy? Or would it have isolated the American experiment and expedited the decline of our democracy? These historical what-ifs are intriguing, if inconclusive. To me, this just signals the importance of owning the present as history-in-the-making, wondering less about what might have been and more about what might still be.
"The man who does not read good books has no advantage over the man who can't read them."

My brain wants to agree with this in general, but I can't get past the "good books" phrase.

Aren't "good books" like "good art" — relative? Who gets to decide what constitutes a good vs bad book? I feel like that's a very slippery slope.

And... What's the criteria for a good book? Who is the authority on this criteria and why are they the authority?

Even if you're reading "bad books," you still have the advantage over the other man because you have the ability to read.
Well that's right, as lots of educators say: better that the kids read Captain Underpants than nothing at all.

But I do still think there's such a thing as a Good Book-- and there are many of them, not just one. It's true that we always have to ask about the ulterior agenda of those who propose to canonize any books. But I will always argue that Twain is better than Danielle Steele, for instance. Walker Percy and Shelby Foote wrote better books than just about any on the current bestseller list. We can and should differ, and debate, about what books are good, and why we think so. But if we throw in the towel and say its all just relative and subjective, then we might as well give up any hope for an enlightenment project of any sort. "Betterment" and "progress" require the exercise of critical judgment, not its abandonment. Sapere Aude! But then also have the courage to expose your own critical judgment to the critical scrutiny of your peers. (What's the Latin for "Have the courage to co-philosophize"?)
Habent animos cooperari, says my Latin translator. Doesn't have quite the Kantian ring to it. Dare operam is better. But I think Sam Fleischacker is right, as reported by our text, that Kant's great question is indeed "an invitation to public discussion in which diversity of opinion will flourish" as to what enlightenment really is. Doesn't mean all those opinions are equally correct. Let's discuss.

Robertson raises the philosophers' dispute over metaphysical foundations. Do we need them, as Alasdair MacIntytre said? Or not, per Richard Rorty? I'm with Rorty in this one, but not quite in the way Robertson characterizes it. Minds can "establish" truths (not Truth) but not finally settle them, not in the way a mirror can settle the matter of one's appearance. Truth happens to ideas, they become true or false depending on the non-arbitrary (hence non-relative)varieties of context and history etc. etc. Or so we Jamesians would wish to establish. But that's Inside Baseball, as it were. And this particular ball is in the tall weeds beyond the fence, better leave it alone.

Finally, I think, Robertson sounds the right concluding note. Enlightenment is about our "willingness to engage with change in this world independent of the next, to think about what might constitute 'progress'." We need to think hard about that, but not (again) only think.



 

 


Monday, May 31, 2021

Notches in time

“‘What are you doing now?’ he asked. ‘Do you keep a journal?’ So I make my first entry to-day.”

So wrote 20-year-old Henry David Thoreau in 1837, encouraged by his friend Emerson. The result was two million words in 14 volumes, composed in the remaining 24 years of a life foreshortened by tuberculosis. According to Walden.org, Thoreau's journal "was his most prized possession and the only one he kept locked up when he went out for walks while living at Walden Pond." He did not suffer the possession of too much stuff.

Younger Daughter (like Older Daughter) has expressed literary ambitions, and has even proposed a collaboration. I'd be honored. Tomorrow she turns 22. I'm going to ask her the question Emerson asked Henry, and present her with the elegant blank book I've been holding on to for a while now. It seems too pretty to mar with my inelegant script, but I think she's its rightful owner. 

A writer's journal is more than a diary, it's a receptacle for all kinds of miscellany (they actually used to call them Miscellany Books, and Day Books), random quotes, fleeting thoughts, partially-baked ideas, project reminders, recipes, notes-to-self... it's a bin for the seed-corn that may one day grow into something lovely and nourishing. 

And if it doesn't, well, the nectar is in the journey. Or maybe the better metaphor of the writing process is Henry's own. "In any weather, at any hour of the day or night, I have been anxious to improve the nick of time, and notch it on my stick too; to stand on the meeting of two eternities, the past and future, which is precisely the present moment; to toe that line."

Remember Henry's hike, Younger Daughter?



Or as Virginia Woolf's Bloomsbury intimate Vita Sackville-West wrote to her,

“It is necessary to write, if the days are not to slip emptily by. How else, indeed, to clap the net over the butterfly of the moment? For the moment passes, it is forgotten; the mood is gone; life itself is gone. That is where the writer scores over his fellows: he catches the changes of his mind on the hop.”

Notch the stick, toe the line, snag the butterfly, enjoy the journey. Writing isn't always easy , but often enough it is its own reward.





Sunday, May 30, 2021

Our "forever young" anniversary

 Twenty-eight years, today, of intermittent matrimonial bliss... along with all the other normal feelings in the full human range of response to the difficult but worthy challenge of syncing two lives, and then three, and then four. This was a special year, when we both turned the age Paul McCartney mused about when he was twenty-two, and when we saw Younger Daughter walk the stage to receive her diploma. 

We binged a lot of Parenthood this spring and thus heard Dylan crooning his recurrently earnest homage to eternal youth. And this is also the year when we're finally addressing the debility that's made me feel older than I should. Surgery is dead ahead. Hoping to get the spring back in my stride before the year is out.

So this is our "forever young" anniversary. May we stay just that way.

This is a nice version too.

 





  

Friday, May 28, 2021

Percy's "search" & Foote's happy labor

 Walker Percy is still my favorite southern Catholic Existentialist novelist...

It’s the birthday of novelist Walker Percy (books by this author), born in Birmingham, Alabama (1916). He was working as a psychiatrist when he caught tuberculosis and he spent two years recovering from the disease. In bed he started reading existentialist philosophers and decided to become a writer. He later said, “[Tuberculosis was] the best disease I ever had. If I hadn’t had it, I might be a second-rate shrink practicing in Birmingham, at best.” He’s best known for his first novel, The Moviegoer (1961), about a stockbroker who tries to get over a nervous breakdown by spending all his time at the movies. WA

And he's still my favorite Tea House co-constructionist. His pal Shelby Foote is still my favorite southern semi-reconstructed southern Proustian Civil War historian and Ken Burns talking head. (Mississippi, for such a benighted state, has produced more than its share of terrific writers. Richard Ford's another favorite on the trail.)

Foote and Percy had a marvelous lifelong friendship [g'r] and (as he told CSPAN) a wonderful correspondence. Percy died in 1990, Foote in 2005.

At the beginning of that CSPAN interview Foote told the humorless Brian Lamb that writers are unhappy people, but near the end of it he had a delightfully different message about the connection between meaningful work and happiness. It's also what he told the Paris Review in 1999:

“People say, My God, I can’t believe that you really worked that hard for twenty years. How in God’s name did you do it? Well, obviously I did it because I enjoyed it. I don’t deserve any credit for working hard. I was doing what I wanted to do. Shakespeare said it best: “The labor we delight in physics pain.” There’s no better feeling in the world than to lay your head on the pillow at night looking forward to getting up in the morning and returning to that desk. That’s real happiness.”

I went searching for his Memphis home, and found it down the street from Rhodes College (taking a break from moving Older Daughter into her dorm) in 2013. There is a sadness to "empty rooms" but also an invaluable reminder. Gather ye rosebuds. Carpe diem. Sic transit gloria.

"One secret of the longevity of our friendship was that each of us knew what would make the other angry, and we were careful not to venture into such areas—except on purpose, which would open the matter to drumfire argument and laughter, time and time again, all down the years.” 


 

Renowned biographer Walter Isaacson was inspired by Percy.
One summer I read Walker Percy’s “The Moviegoer,” and it dawned on me that writing was something you could do for a living, just like being a doctor or a fisherman. The novel’s wry philosophical depth opened my eyes to what Percy called “the search,” poking around for clues about why we are here. At the end of that summer, I tried to get him to expound on the religious themes in the book, but he fended me off. “There are two types of people who come out of Louisiana,” he said. “Preachers and storytellers.” It was better to be a storyteller.
Percy inspired me too, not with his theology– definitely not– but with his wonderful stories, and a style of detached observation that was humane, sympathetic, funny, and indeed searching.

Searchers are implicit optimists, by my definition: they’re on the trail of something, they’re curious and hopeful. They may have met despair but they’ve chosen not to act and live in it. Like Sisyphus.

And maybe like poet May Sarton, whose birthday it also is. “It’s not for me — religion. It seems like a redundancy for a poet.” And some philosophers and storytellers.

An old post:

Walker Percy would have been 100 today  [105 in 2021]
He was a Christian existentialist with a literary sensibility I nonetheless found irresistible when I first read him in the seventies. I’m still amused by his characters’ understated humor and quiet rebellion against what he saw as our lost and fallen condition. He tried to pick a fight with Carl Sagan in Lost in the Cosmos, also more amusing than annoying. His lifelong friendship and correspondence with Shelby Foote is an inspiration. I love the mental picture of young Foote on Faulkner’s porch in Oxford while young Percy waits in the car, too embarrassed to meet his hero. Percy, Foote, & Faulkner

“You can’t make a living writing articles for The Journal of Philosophy and Phenomenological Research. The thought crossed my mind: Why not do what French philosophers often do and Americans almost never — novelize philosophy, incarnate ideas in a person and a place, which latter is, after all, a noble Southern tradition in fiction.” It’s not as easy as he makes it sound. He didn’t have many rivals, doesn’t have many successors. Richard Ford is kind of a secular Percy. I’m searching for others.

“Search” is Percy’s big theme. His heroes search for God and make fun of people like me, who search for godless happiness, purpose, and meaning. But the search is the thing, whatever its quarry. “The search is what anyone would undertake if he were not sunk in the everydayness of his own life. To become aware of the possibility of the search is to be onto something. Not to be onto something is to be in despair.”

It was such a surprise and delight to stumble across and rent the “teahouse” Percy and Foote built near “Lost Cove” in Sewanee, Tennessee in the thirties, twenty years ago. When I wrote of it later I heard from Percy’s grandson, who was searching for it. Really.

Walker Percy and Shelby Foote built this "tea house" in Sewanee TN 

on Percy's uncle's property overlooking "Lost Cove," in the '30s... I found it c.'96.


Wednesday, May 26, 2021

Luxury

LISTEN. What a luxury it is, after last semester when I taught on Tuesdays from my lonely office all day long, to have time on Tuesdays before Enlightenment class begins at 6 pm to respond to all the late student posts. Funny how it makes for better classes, when we've actually thought about what we want to say.

I'm trying gently to encourage us all to post earlier in the week, so we'll have ample time and opportunity to reflect in advance on one another's questions and reflections. But I dashed off a few last-minute thoughts late in the afternoon yesterday that strike me as, well, good enough. Better than nothing, which is what I often had to settle for offering our Democracy class when I was teaching all day before we began at 6. (Had to squeeze in an hour at the Boulevard with Younger Daughter in her final semester, after all.)

What I've noticed is that Garrison Keillor was right (did he write this somewhere, or just say it?), when he said of his habit of writing Lake Wobegon scripts but then going on stage sans notes and winging it, that if you've written down what you intend to say then it'll be in your head, more or less. You'll say something that sounds fresh and spontaneous, because the specific formulation you end up uttering will not be read but roughly recollected.

So, sans questions and context, here's some of what I wrote shortly before class. I'll bet, if I checked the recording, I'd see that I said something like this in class. Or at least something more thoughtful than it would have been, had I written nothing at all.

On the religious spectrum I'm definitely in the non-theist camp. I believe there probably are no gods, at least not of the omnipotent/omniscient/omni-benevolent variety. I also believe in what they used to call the religion of humanity. So I guess that makes me some variety of humanist and naturalist. But I'm also a defender of William James's approach to "the varieties of religious experience," meaning that I--like he--support the right of individuals to decide for themselves what they believe. I simply urge them to be sure that their beliefs accord with their own experience, and that they not interfere with others' equal right to (dis)believe. Like James, I believe in believing -- but not in coercing others to share any particular belief or dogma.

"Adopt but qualify" is my approach to pretty much everything. I've very bad at responding to questionnaires, I always want to interpret the questions and qualify my replies.
==
That's great: [Enlightenment is a never-ending process, ideally. And it's never too late or too early to begin. Ideally, I think, it begins in childhood under the nurturing care of loving parents who give their children quality time and attention, read to them a lot, encourage their questions, respond honestly to them, etc. Parents who shrug off the Big Questions of childhood, or who insist on instilling very particular beliefs and attitudes in their progeny from the earliest years, are in my opinion doing a tremendous disservice to their kids and to society at large. Emerson said to such parents "you're trying to create another you. One is enough!"

Of course many kids, through no fault of their own, are denied quality nurture. For them, we as a society need to step up and support their education from pre-K forward. I've always loved what John Dewey said: "What the best and wisest parents want for their children, that must society want for all children."

I also think we need to encourage philosophical curiosity from the earliest ages. Philosophy with children is a growing movement, and it's a great idea. I believe we'd do a better job of creating a society of adults if we began by philosophizing with kids. (That's what Rousseau thought too, it's what his book "Emile" was about.)

And that prompted me to share Christopher Phillips's crusade to get everyone, and especially everyone of tender years, to reflect and converse philosophically. I remain convinced that we'd be better and better off (a phrase of John Lachs's) if more of us had been encouraged in childhood to embrace our curiosity and share it.

Writing does trigger shareable associations. I wrote: One reason Deism was so popular during the Enlightenment was that it pre-dated Darwin. Many 18th century Deists (Voltaire for instance) might have considered natural selection a sufficient explanation of life's processes (if not yet of its ultimate origins) to let go of God. Personally, though, I'm fine with the Deist assertion of divine indifference to our fate. Whether you're a Deist or a Darwinian agnostic or an atheist, you believe we have to paddle our own canoes and not count on divine intervention to save us from our own foibles.

And "let go" reminded me of Julia Sweeney. I think a class called Enlightenment Now needs to hear her story, but I'm not sure I'd have remembered to say so if I hadn't written those other things first. So the moral is: write on. 

And listen to Jane Kenyon. “Be a good steward of your gifts. Protect your time. Feed your inner life. Avoid too much noise. Read good books, have good sentences in your ears. Be by yourself as often as you can. Walk. Take the phone off the hook. Work regular hours.”

And as Emerson is said to have said, 

“Finish every day and be done with it. You have done what you could; some blunders and absurdities no doubt crept in; forget them as soon as you can. Tomorrow is a new day; you shall begin it serenely and with too high a spirit to be encumbered with your old nonsense.”

And

“Live in the sunshine, swim in the sea, drink the wild air.” Because, as he definitely did say, "it is a luxury to draw the breath of life."

And keep a journal.


Tuesday, May 25, 2021

Jefferson's Bible, Hume's Guide, Emerson's Address

LISTEN. In our Enlightenment Now course, zooming again this evening, we take up a number of questions prompted by Robertson's Very Short Introduction. Two in particular interest me:

  • The "Enlightenment Bible" may not have undermined revelation (30), but what about the Jefferson Bible?
  • What do you think of David Hume's view that Christians "supported their elevation of the next world above the present with a morality of self-denial," and that this is antithetical to what is naturally "useful and agreeable"?
Jefferson thought Jesus naturalized was a "sublime" moral teacher: "To the corruptions of christianity I am indeed opposed; but not to the genuine precepts of Jesus himself. I am a Christian in the only sense in which he wished any one to be; sincerely attached to his doctrines, in preference to all others; ascribing to himself every human excellence, and believing he never claimed any other."

Bertrand Russell famously rejected the notion of Jesus as among the "best and wisest" moral teachers.
I now want to say a few words upon a topic which I often think is not quite sufficiently dealt with by Rationalists, and that is the question whether Christ was the best and the wisest of men. It is generally taken for granted that we shall all agree that that was so. I do not myself. I think that there are a good many points upon which I agree with Christ a great deal more than the professing Christians do. I do not know that I could go with Him all the way, but I could go with Him much farther than most professing Christians can. You will remember that He said: ‘Resist not evil, but whosoever shall smite thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also.’ That is not a new precept or a new principle. It was used by Lao-Tze and Buddha some five or six hundred years before Christ, but it is not a principle which as a matter of fact Christians accept... (continues)

Russell's major and most serious indictment is against the teaching of a punitive afterlife for those who've "committed the sin against the Holy Ghost" and must thus anticipate an eternity of torturous hellfire. "I really do not think that a person with a proper degree of kindliness in his nature would have put fears and terrors of that sort into the world."

And then "there is the curious story of the fig-tree" Jesus cursed to death even though "it was not the right time of year for figs, and you really could not blame the tree." Buddha and Socrates would not have been so intemperate, nor would they ever have invoked supernatural powers to punish the innocent. And that's why Russell was not a Christian. He did not think Christ was the best and wisest, let alone divine. And, btw, he did not believe in God or immortality. 

Julian Baggini's new book on Hume is out today. We've noted in previous classes (particularly Democracy in America, last semester) that the best defense of Hume against the charge of racism is to be found in his own philosophical skepticism: had he taken it truly to heart, he'd not have penned those odious sentiments in the first place. That's Baggini's line, anyway.

"Hume's philosophy is grounded in an honest assessment of nature--human nature in particular... [The Great Guide] follows Hume on his life's journey, literally walking in the great philosopher's footsteps as Baggini takes readers to the places that inspired Hume the most, from his family estate near the Scottish border to Paris, where, as an older man, he was warmly embraced by French society. Baggini shows how Hume put his philosophy into practice in a life that blended reason and passion, study and leisure, and relaxation and enjoyment. The Great Guide includes 145 Humean maxims for living well, on topics ranging from the meaning of success and the value of travel to friendship, facing death, identity, and the importance of leisure." g'r

We'll see if Hume's assessment of human nature is honest, accurate, and adequately inclusive. What we can be sure of, in advance, is that it's thoroughly naturalistic. It may not be "sublime," but is it enlightened? 

And was our University president's decision, announced yesterday?

"Effective immediately, and in accordance with guidance from federal and state public health officials, I am removing campus mandates for the wearing of masks, maintaining social distancing and observing modified COVID-19 room capacities..."
==
Postscript. Just learned it's Emerson's birthday...




Saturday, May 22, 2021

"A morning star"

 Seriously contemplating an indelible iteration of this image, on the canvas of an appendage. 

image.png 

It'd be best to "let it alone," maybe. Henry'd probably say so. 

But sometimes an impulsive act just feels like the life-affirming thing to do. Henry's sun has set anyway.

How long can you contemplate a thing, though, before it loses the quality of impulse? 'Til Tuesday?

image.png 

The light which puts out our eyes is darkness to us. 

Only that day dawns to which we are awake. 

There is more day to dawn. 

The sun is but a morning star.


Postscript, Wednesday May 26. Went to see a tattoo artist yesterday, and talked to another. It's definitely going to happen, I'm going to wear at least a part of my identity just below my sleeve. I shall join the legion of ink-stained wretrches. Or so I feel today. 

Friday, May 21, 2021

Spring cleaning

 It has begun, the big project I've postponed for years. Decades. The clean-up, or clean-out, of my Little House. My wife insists: everything must come out, much must go. She's not wrong. 

 

 
“I’ve been escaping the world here since 1996. It’s accumulated a  
lot of “stuff” (see George Carlin) over the years, some of which
probably needs to go. It all certainly needs a good cleaning. So that’s
about to happen, we’re going to cart everything out into the sunshine
and see what’s worth bringing back. The place will never be the same
again - for better or worse. So here’s a little tour, before the purge.”

Electricians are coming to re-wire it today. Someone else is coming to help empty it next week. My job now is to begin sorting and boxing, getting stuff organized and transportable. The goal is to make the place better than it was before, a cleaner and more efficient workspace/retreat (I refuse to call it a "Man Cave").

The job has its satisfactions. Yesterday I went through the glass cabinet that contains my little shrine to baseball, and uncovered a few delights. 

There were all those old autographed baseballs, including the one I got Joe Torre to sign back in the early '70s when he played for the Cardinals, right before my sister's old Doberman Pinscher "Bo" teethed on it...



and the one I caught in the upper grandstand of Al Lang Stadium (before the "Devil Rays," before the desecration of futbol) during Spring Training of 1992, the only ball I've ever snagged at a major league contest (off the bat of the Phillies' Dale Sveum, later a Brewers and Cubs manager)...



And there was the autographed copy of George Plimpton's wonderful April Fool's saga of Siddhartha Finch, the book that I got him to sign in Cooperstown a couple of years before his death (his hearing must have been a bit off)...

 

And the mugs my dad bought for me, when the Cards won in '67 and lost to KC (and the 1st base ump) in '85. (Dad and I attended game 5 at old Busch Stadium.)

 
Another reminder: I don't know what time is, but I do know it's the most precious thing we have in shortest supply. So, time spent revisiting treasured artifacts of times gone by is anything but wasted. I almost look forward to getting back out there and rummaging some more.

==
Postscript. More interesting objects pulled out of the clutter...

  
This photo w/Older Daughter c.'96


 

 

 

And most ironically...



This all calls for a musical interlude. In '98 this was Older Daughter's favorite song:


"A man is rich in proportion to the number of things which he can afford to let alone." Henry nailed it, once again.
==
Postscript, May 29. Let a lot of things alone, once the dust settled, but hauled a lot away too. Gonna miss that chair...

    









Thursday, May 20, 2021

Time and singularity

 The latest Vandy alumni magazine reports what I already knew, but seeing it in print makes it emphatic and real. My old mentor, and my old classmate, are both stepping down. 

 

I shared this in a text to several far-flung pals. One quoted his recently-late father's late lament: "I don't know what time is."

John Lachs, I learned in this notice, supervised 72 Ph.D dissertations in his decades of service to Vanderbilt. I'm proud  and humbled to have been one of them.

One of my early Nashville memories is a scene from my first summer here, the summer before the election of Ronald Reagan. Bandas and some others of our young cohort were gathered on a porch on Belcourt Avenue near campus, as he held forth and proclaimed the impending decline and fall of American civilization as we knew it. He projected a cynical, imposing edge. "Badass," we'd later call that attitude and mien. (Now, if you met him on the street, you might discern a different resemblance. Ned?) Someone else on that porch, if memory serves, said things weren't as bad as he said. Time will tell. Or has it already?

So what is time? I just know that it keeps on slipping slipping slipping... And flattening, and shrinking. In retrospect, if we're lucky, it will represent us in others' memory as a single clarifying note. William James in 1903 remembered his godfather Emerson that way: "...when the days of one's life are ended, those days that were so crowded with business and felt so heavy in their passing, what remains of one in memory [is] so slight a thing. The phantom of an attitude, the echo of a certain mode of thought, a few pages of print, some invention, or some victory we gained in a brief critical hour, are all that can survive the best of us... happy are those whose singularity gives a note so clear as to be victorious over the inevitable pity of such a diminution and abridgement."

I hope my friends are happy. It certainly makes me happy to recall them, as they were and as they are. Happy retirement, gentlemen.






Wednesday, May 19, 2021

Flying into the light

Enjoyed our first Enlightenment class last night, we mostly just introduced ourselves and shared our respective notions of what "enlightenment" might mean. I wanted to emphasize the point that enlightenment in the western philosophical sense is decidedly not about finding a singular sage or guru with privileged insight into reality, truth, and meaning. It is about the collaborative conversation that attempts to corral as many points of view and fields of experience as can be gathered, so to yield a wider comprehension of (in James's phrase) "our more or less dumb sense of what life honestly and deeply means."

And, I wanted to highlight the distinction between The Enlightenment, as a particular historical era, and enlightenment per se as an attitude and approach to reason and feeling, head and heart, science and humanism and progress etc. that transcends any particular time and place. 

We're trying in our course, in other words, to identify core enlightenment values that we may now share with that earlier moment and build upon, to better meet the challenges of our own day.

And that aspiration prompted one of us to wonder about the limits of historical interpretation. Can we be sure that their Enlightenment values may translate constructively into enlightenment in the 21st century and beyond?

Good question. I mentioned Wittgenstein's notion of a family resemblance between concepts, and averred that that's all we need: not perfect translation, just a sense that we're playing in the same ballpark. I think we are. We'll see.

The student who raised the historiographic concern also shared a metaphor I like. "As I walk down the hallway into the darkness I know there is a door that might be halfway opened..." It reminded me of James's pragmatic corridor, the idea of negotiating various philosophies and ideas via a central passageway that is the pragmatic method. (He generously, characteristically credited an obscure other, Papini, but it's a fundamentally Jamesian vision.) 

As the young Italian pragmatist Papini has well said, it lies in the midst of our theories, like a corridor in a hotel. Innumerable chambers open out of it. In one you may find a man writing an atheistic volume; in the next someone on his knees praying for faith and strength; in a third a chemist investigating a body's properties. In a fourth a system of idealistic metaphysics is being excogitated; in a fifth the impossibility of metaphysics is being shown. But they all own the corridor, and all must pass through it if they want a practicable way of getting into or out of their respective rooms.

No particular results then, so far, but only an attitude of orientation, is what the pragmatic method means. THE ATTITUDE OF LOOKING AWAY FROM FIRST THINGS, PRINCIPLES, 'CATEGORIES,' SUPPOSED NECESSITIES; AND OF LOOKING TOWARDS LAST THINGS, FRUITS, CONSEQUENCES, FACTS.

So much for the pragmatic method!

And then the darkened hallway also reminded me of the Wallace Stegner quote my wife and I shared in our wedding scroll, nearly 28 years ago...

“The truest vision of life I know is that bird in the Venerable Bede that flutters from the dark into a lighted hall, and after a while flutters out again into the dark. But... It is something--it can be everything--to have found a fellow bird with whom you can sit among the rafters while the drinking and boasting and reciting and fighting go on below; a fellow bird whom you can look after and find bugs and seeds for; one who will patch your bruises and straighten your ruffled feathers and mourn over your hurts when you accidentally fly into something you can't handle." (--from The Spectator Bird)

And it reminded me of Dumbledore, who said happiness is always possible if we just remember to turn on the light. I think that's right.