Delight Springs

Monday, August 31, 2026

Lollygaggers

[Substack]

That’s what we call our old Vandy grad school cohort which gathers once a year late in summer, a name culled from the Durham Bulls in the old Kevin Costner film. (“It’s a long season, you gotta trust it,” said Crash Davis.) 

We’ve just concluded another great Lollygaggers August reunion, the this time in Birmingham. (We always pick a minor league venue most of us can drive to, from our various points on the compass.) We’ve been doing these annual meetups since 2017. Now most of us are retired. For a weekend every summer we still get to feel, just slightly and sporadically, like our old young ‘80s student selves. It’s good, rejuvenating even, to stay in touch with those youngsters. I recommend it, class of 2030. 

Next August in Knoxville (on our 10th anniversary) I’m going to see if I can get the guys to reminisce, on the record, about what it has meant to each of them to be an American philosopher/academic in our peculiar times. We all have stories to tell, and memories more or less intact. More than half a millennium’s worth of aggregated years between us, at an average age of 70 each. That’s a lot of lifelong learning! Speak, memory. Before we forget.

Uploaded Image Uploaded Image

Uploaded Image Uploaded Image

Tuesday, August 25, 2026

How I'll greet the class of 2030 today

In addition to our usual "Who are you, why are you here" (etc.) introductions, we'll talk about what philosophy is (getting philosophers to agree about that really is like herding cats) and our personal favorites.

Philosophy Bites, Nihilism vs. Meliorism

Nigel Warburton’s podcast, a good supplement to his Little History of Philosophy (which we are reading): https://philosophybites.com/

If you search the site for "definitions of philosophy" this comes up... including an episode from 2010 that asks numerous contemporary philosophers What is Philosophy? No two answers are the same. Philosophers do tend to think for themselves. The good ones, though, do not think by themselves. They converse and collaborate. They're Co-Philosophers, like we aim to be in this course.

My own definition of philosophy, beyond the etymological/literal "love of wisdom," is William James's: "an unusually stubborn attempt to think clearly," and to live in the light of that clarity.

And my own personal philosophy, if reduced to a word, is decidedly not Sally Brown's "No!" That's too much like deep pessimism or even nihilism.


No, the word I'd choose is: meliorism. You'll hear it again. 

It rejects pure optimism and deep pessimism alike. It means trying to make things better. And it comes from, guess who... "Willie" James (as one of mty old Vandy mentors familiarly called my favorite philosopher who's been dead but not gone for 116+ years now. In Pragmatism-"a new name for some old ways of thinking" dedicated 

To the Memory of John Stuart Mill

from whom I first learned the pragmatic openness of mind
and whom my fancy likes to picture as our leader were he alive to-day.

he writes:

...there are unhappy men who think the salvation of the world impossible. Theirs is the doctrine known as pessimism.

Optimism in turn would be the doctrine that thinks the world's salvation inevitable.

Midway between the two there stands what may be called the doctrine of meliorism, tho it has hitherto figured less as a doctrine than as an attitude in human affairs. Optimism has always been the regnant DOCTRINE in european philosophy. Pessimism was only recently introduced by Schopenhauer and counts few systematic defenders as yet. Meliorism treats salvation as neither inevitable nor impossible. It treats it as a possibility, which becomes more and more of a probability the more numerous the actual conditions of salvation become.

It is clear that pragmatism must incline towards meliorism...

Me too.

Monday, August 24, 2026

Independence matters

MTSU's Fall '26 convocation Saturday afternoon gathered the class of 2030, a nice round scifi-sounding graduation date for my last Opening Day classes tomorrow. The speaker was historian Edward Larson, author of the freshman summer read Declaring Independence: Why 1776 Matters as well as the prize-winning account of the 1925 Scopes Trial Summer of the Gods which we read in my MALA "Evolution in America" course. TrueBlueTV recorded it. He begins at about the 38-minute mark.

I appreciated his call to our new students to seize the spirit of '76 and Tom Paine's Common Sense, and each to pursue their own life, liberty, and happiness in the full freedom of independent thought and cultivated character. Hope they were listening.



Friday, August 21, 2026

Applied Philosophy Lyceum: Oct 2, 5 pm, COE 164

The Digital Cave

Reading, Thinking, and Dwelling in the Age of the Algorithm

An Applied Philosophy Talk by John Kaag

Abstract

We live in an era of industrial-scale shadow-play. The map of reality is no longer drawn from our own experience but projected by algorithms designed to keep us looking at a particular kind of wall. This talk argues that the oldest resources in the philosophical canon offer the most precise diagnosis of our newest predicament. Plato's cave anticipates the architecture of the feed—with one grim perversion: his prisoners at least shared a wall, while the algorithm builds a bespoke cavern for each of us. The Buddhist vocabulary of maya, tanha, and upadana describes with uncanny accuracy the mechanics of craving, clinging, and curated selfhood that the infinite scroll exploits. And Heidegger's account of Enframing—read alongside his catastrophic biography, which cannot be waved away—explains how attention itself became “standing reserve,” a resource to be extracted.

The talk concludes with the question increasingly posed to our machines: why is talking to a large language model so strange? The answer reveals a schism between information and meaning, between the calculative synthesis at which AI excels and the meditative, embodied, abductive thinking that a life—with something at stake—alone makes possible. Philosophy's task has not changed since the cave: to make us suspicious of the reality that appears most obvious, and to recover the gritty practices that might let us turn our heads, a few degrees, toward the light.

About the Speaker

John Kaag is Professor of Philosophy at the University of Massachusetts Lowell, External Professor at the Santa Fe Institute, and Visiting Professor at Harvard Divinity School. He is the author of three widely acclaimed books published by Farrar, Straus and Giroux: American Philosophy: A Love Story, Hiking with Nietzsche: On Becoming Who You Are, and Sick Souls, Healthy Minds: How William James Can Save Your Life. These books were named NPR Best Books of the Year and New York Times Editors' Choice selections.

His work bridges American pragmatism, intellectual history, ethics, and the philosophy of technology, and he writes regularly for general audiences on why philosophy still matters for everyday life.

Tuesday, August 18, 2026

“It could be worse”

Kurt Andersen’s novel The Breakup is out today. I’ve been looking forward to it. 

Are we middle Tennesseans living in the future “Free American Republic,” the post-split remnant of Red State America Andersen imagines? He’s an astute observer of our fractured Fantasyland, I’m not betting against him. But if this is a cautionary tale, maybe national reconciliation is not yet entirely how did the question. That’s a much bigger gamble. Anyway, and to look on the slightly-brighter side, I’m sure he’s right: It could be worse. Still can be. For now, this is just a good story we should take seriously. Less “active contempt” for our neighbors would be a positive step away from the brink.

“…I so badly wanted the crazy experiment of the United States of America to continue defying the odds, as always. Anyhow, what I said earlier about the half-life of the war’s traumas is true. But what to me feels even better is the fading of what preceded it—the compulsive politicization of everything, the fear and hatred of the Other Side as an animating, irresistible everyday emotion. The active contempt has become less salient, diminished, including in rural Middle Tennessee, where I’ve lived for all but a few months for the last decade. “I don’t disagree about the vibe shift, honey,” says my local best friend Victoria, who grew up around here and lives fifteen minutes away. “But isn’t it also true for you right now because you don’t have Asher around to bicker with so much?” 

At first I found the term “Disunion” too clinical and wonky. But it is more correctly mutual than “secession.” And has some history, dignity, a touch of grandeur. I’m a fan of all those. But I call it the breakup. It’s a little glib, but simple, factual, neutral, idiomatic, and broad enough to cover the whole era, beginning to end. It’s also a universally familiar concept, unlike Disunion. It’s relatable. Americans have been strange bedfellows in a mixed marriage for a long time. We grew apart. We stayed together, but finally came to find each other impossible. We fought. We had irreconcilable differences. We finally split. In a world where half the marriages unravel or rot or die of thirst or blow up. Or do whatever mine’s doing. A clichéd question about America since I was a kid concerned our national political “fever,” if and when it would ever break. The fever broke. Along with our beautiful, uncomfortable, brittle, breakable antique national governing arrangements, now being rebuilt and refurbished. It could be worse.” — The Breakup: A Novel by Kurt Andersen

Monday, August 17, 2026

Addicted to study

School starts in a week. Time to celebrate one of the more positive addictions.

“…As obvious as this may seem, it typically goes unsaid: to be a student is ... to study. Students are not clients; they are not consumers; they are not users who can be “captured” by outcomes, indicators, or throughputs. Experts recognize this fact, yet study is not a main theme or even a topic in the shelf of books I have on recent debates. Few philosophical arguments about the future of the university analyze what it means to study. 

So before we go any further, let the first idea of this book be the idea of study. What, this humanities professor asks, does the word student mean? In the academic field of higher education, students are the subject matter for vast research. But philosophers often examine what seems obvious, and, to me, this idea of study especially has the power to help reorient the research university. Framing the idea of study means making explicit a goal that exceeds our current practices. 

Framing the idea of study does not mean offering an empirical account of what students today “do.” Rather, it is an attempt to identify the ideas that may guide them. With some irony, I’ll try to outline the idea of study by exploring the words student and study as documented by the Oxford English Dictionary, which emerged from the philological research of great humanities scholars. 

So let me link, or turn to, the 1989 version of the Oxford English Dictionary, conveniently available to students and faculty online. student, n. 1. A person who is engaged in or addicted to study. 2. a. A person who is undergoing a course of study and instruction at a university or other place of higher education or technical training. Also const. of, in (a subject); often with defining word prefixed, as art student, law student, medical student...”

— What Could a University Be?: Revolutionary Ideas for the Future (On Campus) by Robert B. Gibbs

Saturday, August 15, 2026

Moving on up

Began moving office yesterday. Trying to embrace a minimalist style this time, since I’m departing in May. My first office at MTSU was windowless. My second was tiny. This is better on both counts.

Uploaded Image

Thursday, August 13, 2026

Following the moon, walking the path

Drove S to her PT session in Green Hills the other morning and, while waiting, decided to replicate my own post-surgical PT routine of five summers ago when I'd reward myself after every session by wandering over to Parnassus Books and the Donut Den. 

Glad I did, the apple fritter and the chocolate-covered creme-filled continue to delight; and I discovered an "adult fable" in the philosophy section that reminded me a lot of Freddie the Leaf.



I used to read Freddie to our girls, probably before they were quite ready to contemplate their mortality. As my last academic year approaches, the time is ripe for pondering my own... not in a morbid mood, but because I intend to enjoy the undiscovered country called Retirement starting in May '27. 

That little pup Amaya is Freddie's counterpart, the Wolf stands in for the wise old leaf who counsels Freddie to embrace every season of life. The path ahead may be a bit hazy, but let's go. [S'stack]



 

Friday, August 7, 2026

The Rossians

Contact, redux (but this would be the prequel, it’s happening during the Carter administration). 

We do need a reshuffling and a renewed sense of wonder. Maybe an alien transmission would be just the thing. But on the other hand, isn’t belief in aliens already pretty ordinary? You don’t have to go light-years away to find (in John Prine‘s words) humans who ain’t human. There seems to be a clutch of them at 1600 Pennsylvania Ave., for instance. 

 But seriously… 

 “…Believing in aliens is suddenly ordinary. 

 It’s a massive reshuffling of cultural norms. 

 For every person who eschews their earthly belongings to go live in a commune, there are countless others who live their lives essentially unchanged. For every horrific, family-shattering suicide, hundreds of thousands of individuals push through their existential dread. The human mind is evolutionarily adapted to finding lessons and silver linings in shocking events, and this isn’t the first time humanity has been de-centered in the universe. Deniers exist, of course. People who insist that the Beacon is a hoax, a lie, a trick; people no amount of evidence can persuade. But overall, a sense of wonder prevails. 

 A name for this newest wonder is chosen: the Rossians. 

 The Rossians are out there, and they are waiting for a reply. There is a sense of power in this, of connection: It’s our move, and we need to move as one. The United Nations is suddenly taken a bit more seriously. Regions coalesce, speaking of unity. Dead-end negotiations sprout sudden exits. Hostages come home. An array of military forces works in concert to keep an eye on the sky as international hostilities cool and relations warm—not all, not everywhere, and in some cases not for long, but noticeably so. It’s a mental tic many people feel: We are not just members of a tribe or nation, we are members of a planet...” — The Radiant Dark: A Novel by Alexandra Oliva https://a.co/0g5DTOmC

Thursday, August 6, 2026

Nagori

Uploaded Image

… and the last year of a teaching career? https://substack.com/@philosophyminis/note/c-308063068?r=35ogp&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=notes-share-action

Wednesday, August 5, 2026

“Why should I strive for happiness?”

Looking forward to John Kaag’s October 2 MTSU Lyceum visit, when I’m sure he’ll affirm the possibility of happiness in work. I’ve decided we’ll read this book in Existentialism just before he arrives (and we’ll read how William James saved his life in CoPhi then, too).

“For Nietzsche, I consoled myself, the point was not about avoiding or even conquering suffering: he recognized, like so many philosophers before him, that suffering was a fundamental fact of human existence. But the ascetic response to suffering was to understand it as a complaint about life. My challenge—the challenge Nietzsche raises—was to embrace life with all its suffering. When he wrote, at the very end of his career, “Have I been understood? Dionysus versus the Crucified,” he meant to show that suffering does not refute life as we experience it but must be welcomed, embraced, in exactly the same way we welcome and embrace happiness. In fact, Nietzsche often sounds as though happiness is at best a kind of secondary goal. In Thus Spoke Zarathustra, Nietzsche’s most famous character, having spent his life in the mountains, concludes: “Happiness? Why should I strive for happiness? I strive for my work.””

— Hiking with Nietzsche: On Becoming Who You Are by John J. Kaag
https://a.co/02BXPDFc

Wednesday, July 29, 2026

Elon’s Academy

We’d better imagine something completely different, and fast. “The scenario that follows,” cartoonish though it is, “is built entirely on Musk’s own statements.” More than “perplexing”… “Imagine a day in 2035. …students port their Neuralinks into Grokipedia modules on history. They learn that the term “slave” originally referred to white people and the British Empire was important mostly for ending African slavery. Terms like “racism” and “sexism” never appear as they have been proven to correlate directly with the “woke mind virus”—considered eradicated since 2032. The great error of history in the dark years of the early twenty-first century was that “weak makes right.” This was part of what is described as the “vampire cult” of education now mercifully superseded. The powerful, she learns, should never apologize. Even great civilizations, though, do not last forever. She absorbs the surprising fact that all empires have fallen for the same reason: low birth rates. Fewer people mean not only less labor power—no longer relevant due to the replacement of almost all workers by humanoid robots—but, more importantly, less human intelligence. As she has been taught many times, intelligence is the “the primary evolutionary vector for humans.” On guard against further decline, her science class teaches her about the latest developments in selective human breeding for higher intelligence, including “iterated embryo selection” which allows for choosing specific genetic alleles and cross-fertilizing them without implanting them in a womb, as well as the now-standard “spell-checking” of genetic code to remove all mutations. Learning about this technology is framed as a patriotic duty to ensure strong offspring and reduce future burdens on the privatized health system. It is incumbent on smart women like her to produce at least 2.1 children. She is reminded again of the self-evident truth that there are only two genders and of the evils of past decades, when people changed their genders in what is now recognized as “child mutilation and sterilization.” Such actions are now punishable by imprisonment. More important of course is the pursuit of digital superintelligence. Advances have already made possible the creation of a fleet of humanoid robots ten times the human population on earth. They are a constant presence on streets and in homes. The school itself is maintained and guarded by them. They also lead the gym class, which doubles as border defense education with drills and carbon-fiber weapons. On the way home, the air is hazy with vapor and filled with a low-level hum from the cooling towers of the Neural Districts—massive data center complexes ringing the city. A Tesla sign on a fence reads “Data is Sovereignty.” Asking her parents why the trees are dead and the streambeds dry, they respond “critical infrastructure.” At home, the lights are dim because “nonessential use” is rationed to supply the data centers at peak hours. She talks to her parents about Mars. Starship is now launching twenty times a day and the rockets have become fully reusable, but the launch window only comes every two years. Promotional videos and gleeful simulations populated by animated companion AIs circulate constantly on X. One more push, one more sacrifice, they all sing, and humanity will ascend.” — Muskism: A Guide for the Perplexed by Quinn Slobodian, Ben Tarnoff https://a.co/0i68r6H4

Saturday, July 25, 2026

Stay woke

“…By 2016, these political expressions had migrated from the margins to center stage. At the Code Conference in San Francisco that summer, Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey appeared beside Black Lives Matter activist DeRay Mckesson wearing a T-shirt that read “# StayWoke.” (The shirts had been made by Black employees at the company after the police killing of Michael Brown in 2014). Everyone in the crowd received their own. 15 “Woke” was a word with deep roots in Black culture: as early as 1938, the folk singer Lead Belly had urged his listeners to “stay woke” in a song about the Scottsboro Boys. Staying woke meant being alert to injustice, and to the likelihood of police and white vigilante violence. 16 Dorsey coopted the term for his own platform. Twitter offered a way to revise the narratives of mainstream journalists and deliver a more authentic perspective on current events. For him, scrolling and posting were the way to remain woke in the contemporary world. In the coming years, the term would become a catch-all for progressive politics, as amplified through the megaphone of social media. Yet the woke social network of #HandsUpDontShoot and #MeToo was always shadowed by its obscene doppelgänger: the internet of trolls. In 2003, a year before Facebook was founded, another tech-savvy teenager launched a website called 4chan. It was a simple message board modeled on a Japanese predecessor named 2chan, and its founder was a fifteen-year-old student from New York City named Christopher “moot” Poole. 4chan was a networked public of pubescent humor and smut, shot through with homophobic, racist, sexist, and ableist slurs. It also incubated many mainstays of internet culture, such as the meme. The term “meme” was first coined by the evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins in the final chapter of his 1976 book The Selfish Gene, where he described it as a “unit of cultural transmission,” such as an idea, song, or style of clothing. By the 2000s, the term had evolved far from its original context to mean a combination of text and image shared online.” — Muskism: A Guide for the Perplexed by Quinn Slobodian, Ben Tarnoff https://a.co/09sdsPgp

Stay woke

“…By 2016, these political expressions had migrated from the margins to center stage. At the Code Conference in San Francisco that summer, Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey appeared beside Black Lives Matter activist DeRay Mckesson wearing a T-shirt that read “# StayWoke.” (The shirts had been made by Black employees at the company after the police killing of Michael Brown in 2014). Everyone in the crowd received their own. 15 “Woke” was a word with deep roots in Black culture: as early as 1938, the folk singer Lead Belly had urged his listeners to “stay woke” in a song about the Scottsboro Boys. Staying woke meant being alert to injustice, and to the likelihood of police and white vigilante violence. 16 Dorsey coopted the term for his own platform. Twitter offered a way to revise the narratives of mainstream journalists and deliver a more authentic perspective on current events. For him, scrolling and posting were the way to remain woke in the contemporary world. In the coming years, the term would become a catch-all for progressive politics, as amplified through the megaphone of social media. Yet the woke social network of #HandsUpDontShoot and #MeToo was always shadowed by its obscene doppelgänger: the internet of trolls. In 2003, a year before Facebook was founded, another tech-savvy teenager launched a website called 4chan. It was a simple message board modeled on a Japanese predecessor named 2chan, and its founder was a fifteen-year-old student from New York City named Christopher “moot” Poole. 4chan was a networked public of pubescent humor and smut, shot through with homophobic, racist, sexist, and ableist slurs. It also incubated many mainstays of internet culture, such as the meme. The term “meme” was first coined by the evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins in the final chapter of his 1976 book The Selfish Gene, where he described it as a “unit of cultural transmission,” such as an idea, song, or style of clothing. By the 2000s, the term had evolved far from its original context to mean a combination of text and image shared online.” — Muskism: A Guide for the Perplexed by Quinn Slobodian, Ben Tarnoff https://a.co/09sdsPgp

Tuesday, July 21, 2026

“more reasonable and respectful”

Enjoying the new Garry Trudeau bio. Daily doses of Doonesbury back in the 70s and 80s shaped my political sensibility as much as anything. Before I encountered James’s message, imploring us always to array our beliefs and acts under the aspect of good,* there was Trudeau urging us to be “for something”… 


 “By the late 1970s, Trudeau morphed into a chronicler of the Zeitgeist; while he would still not hesitate to make fun of the powerful and the famous, he would step up his efforts to address the hypocrisy and ridiculousness at the heart of American culture. And all his efforts would be in service of a larger mission: to help Americans become their own better angels. As he put it in 1990, he was “propelled by a sense of moral indignation, which you hope doesn’t slip into malice when you’re executing. The critical difference is that you’re not only against something, you’re for something. It springs out of a sense of hope.” He was much less invested in opposing any particular individual or institution than in encouraging Americans to become more reasonable and respectful toward one another.” 

 — Trudeau & Doonesbury: A Biography: The Cartoonist Who Turned the News into Art by Joshua Kendall https://a.co/04ixYXsB

==

*Spinoza long ago wrote in his Ethics that anything that a man can avoid under the notion that it is bad he may also avoid under the notion that something else is good. He who habitually acts sub specie mali, under the negative notion, the notion of the bad, is called a slave by Spinoza. To him who acts habitually under the notion of good he gives the name of freeman. See to it now, I beg you, that you make freemen of your pupils by habituating them to act, whenever possible, under the notion of a good. Talks to Teachers...

Thursday, July 9, 2026

Catching thoughts

An Ordinary Mind on an Ordinary Day | Lapham’s Quarterly


Michael Pollan:

[Kalina Christoff Hadjiilieva, a Bulgarian-born psychologist at the University of British Columbia] recently coedited The Oxford Handbook of Spontaneous Thought, an anthology that includes an illuminating essay on the history of spontaneous thought. It describes the routines of several highly accomplished historical figures—including Darwin, Beethoven, Dali, and Chandler—who achieved great success despite working a relatively short day (four to five hours) followed by lots of long walks, afternoon naps, loads of unstructured time, and long vacations. It is often not until we leave our desks to wander, whether in mind or body or both, that inspiration strikes…


Writers attempting to represent the stream of consciousness aim to catch thoughts on the fly, before they have coalesced into complete sentences that can be shared—sentences being how we dress our thoughts to take them out into the world… [Virginia Woolf] manages to evoke the free movement of her characters’ minds without sacrificing sentences and syntax…”*


The philosopher Henri Bergson, one of Marcel Proust’s major influences, believed in the existence of “pure” thought that precedes language, which was liable to distort it. (This was scarcely a new idea: Writing in the eighteenth century, poet and philosopher Friedrich Schiller said, “When the soul speaks, alas, it is no longer the soul that speaks.”) The twentieth-century French writer Nathalie Sarraute felt that more mental contents slipped through the net of interior monologue than were caught by it, including “an immense profusion of sensations, images, sentiments, memories, impulses, little larval actions that no inner language can convey, that jostle one another on the threshold of consciousness.” For those who, like Joyce, did believe that language constitutes our minds, the stream of consciousness represented a radical advance in literary realism.


Those who didn’t, like Proust, rejected the method for being too “oblique.” It drew our attention away from all the nonverbal “mind-stuff” that William James had identified in consciousness, and that Proust worked so hard to capture—albeit in words… 


Adapted from A World Appears: A Journey into Consciousness by Michael Pollan


—

*Or, as Woolf’s friend Vita Sackville-West put it:

“It is necessary to write, if the days are not to slip emptily by. How else, indeed, to clap the net over the butterfly of the moment? For the moment passes, it is forgotten; the mood is gone; life itself is gone. That is where the writer scores over his fellows: he catches the changes of his mind on the hop.” 


Albeit in words.




Monday, June 29, 2026

the right to think for ourselves

A helpful reminder, as we head into the long July 4 250th birthday holiday, of things worthy of rockets' red glare. The public library and its symbolism, for one. 

“…The library was not and is not perfect. Our public library system has been segregated and elitist. At various points in history, public libraries have reinforced white superiority, excluded sexual minorities and elevated men as knowledge’s gatekeepers. And only rarely does it receive consistent, secure funding to fill its many societal roles.

But however imperfect, wherever a public library exists, it is one of the few places where Americans can experience the public life that neoliberalism has defunded and partisanship has demonized. When you walk into one, you know that there are some things too precious to be trusted to corporations or consumer preferences or political influence. A library card is liberal democracy made manifest.

There is a reason that culture warriors hate the library. It is the same reason that Americans should defend it with our lives. No political spin doctor can sell us what is freely given at one: the right to think for ourselves.” Tressie McMillan Cottom


https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/06/25/opinion/america-250-birthday.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share

Wednesday, June 24, 2026

A Sisyphean labor

Jürgen Habermas Defended Reason in a Darkening Age

“…Philosophy is a discipline of abstractions, yet it raises achingly elemental questions. The august Kant asks, “What can I know? What should I do? What can I hope for?” The answers are seldom simple or bright. The seduction of despair can be intense, whether on the personal or the political level. But the fact that most of our hopes remain unrealized should not revoke the reality of our fitful, painful progress. This was Habermas’s core conviction; he was an incrementalist, though a radical one. On the other hand, in his almost manic drive toward consensus, he blunted the edge of his critical inheritance. If we are to say no to the monstrosities that we have unleashed, we need the uncompromising fury that the Frankfurt School writers invested in their work. We need Adorno to tell us that the confusion of truth and lies “makes it a Sisyphean labor to hold on to the simplest piece of knowledge.” In the end, we need both voices: the critical and the reconstructive, the savage and the sage. The dialectic moves between crashing despair and hovering hope.” ♦︎ Alex Ross

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2026/06/22/jurgen-habermas-desperate-fight-for-democracy

Tuesday, June 23, 2026

A very happy Father’s Day

Thanks to Younger Daughter (and her husband) for indulging my Father’s Day request to recreate those fondly-recalled wiffle ball games of her childhood. We set up bases out in Dogland, but let the funny-looking quadruped kids run them. What a blast!

Uploaded Image